Transparent Amorphous Silica to Model Clay
Magued G. Iskander, P.E., M.ASCE
1
; Jinyuan Liu, S.M.ASCE
2
; and Samer Sadek, S.M.ASCE
3
Abstract: The fundamental premise of this research is that transparent synthetic materials with geotechnical properties similar to natural
soils can be used in model tests to study three-dimensional deformation and flow problems using nonintrusive optical visualization
techniques. The transparent ‘‘clays’’ discussed in this paper were made by consolidating suspensions of amorphous silica in a pore fluid
with a matching refractive index. Conventional triaxial compression, consolidation, and permeability tests were performed to study the
behavior of the material under normally consolidated and overconsolidated conditions. This paper demonstrates the feasibility of produc-
ing a family of transparent materials, which can be customized to exhibit shear-strength, pore-pressure, volume-change, and permeability
characteristics that are consistent with the behavior of natural clays.
DOI: 10.1061/ASCE1090-02412002128:3262
CE Database keywords: Shear strength; Clay; Imaging techniques; Model tests; Silica.
Introduction
Imaging technologies are increasingly being used to study many
geotechnical problems. For example, a system has been devel-
oped to study the distribution of voids in soil specimens Frost
and Kuo 1996. A vision cone has also been developed for in situ
soil exploration Raschke and Hryciw 1997, and techniques were
developed to use its captured images in soil characterization Hry-
ciw et al. 1997. Optical techniques have also been used in model
studies to measure the response of transparent materials, which
model specific soil properties. For example, translucent media
made of crushed glass and a matched refractive index fluid have
been used to study stress distribution under simple shear Al-
lersma 1982, as well as the response of saturated embankments
under seismic loading Konagai et al. 1992. However, the study
of soil response using optical techniques is limited by the lack of
a transparent material that can accurately model the properties of
natural soils.
The development of transparent materials that can be custom-
ized to meet model test requirements is the necessary foundation
for utilizing optical techniques to study spatial deformation pat-
terns and flow characteristics in three-dimensional 3D transpar-
ent soil models. Two families of transparent materials are being
developed for modeling sand and clay. The first family, which
models sand, is made of transparent silica gels and matched re-
fractive index pore fluid Sadek et al. 2002. The second family,
discussed in this paper, is made by consolidating suspensions of
amorphous silica and liquids with matched refractive indices and
was found to model the geotechnical properties of natural clays
Iskander et al. 1994; Iskander 1997, 1998. Both families have
the same refractive index and use the same pore fluids, thus per-
mitting their use in the same model Fig. 1.
The material described in this paper has been used, with
simple optical techniques, to measure the response of transparent
soils in model tests. For example, Welker et al. 1999 used color
saturation to study the flow of contaminants into perforated ver-
tical wick drains and Gill 1999 used target tracking to study
pile penetration in clays.
At this time, techniques for measuring spatial deformations in
transparent soils are being developed. Transparent soil models are
sliced optically using laser sheets. Digital image correlation of
successive images, taken before and after movement, is being
developed to provide a two-dimensional image of the deformed
shape within each slice. Multiple slices can be used to construct
the complete spatial picture of the deformed mass.
This paper is a comprehensive study of the geotechnical be-
havior of transparent amorphous silica under both normally con-
1
Associate Professor, Polytechnic Univ., 6 Metrotech Center, Brook-
lyn, NY 11201.
2
Graduate Research Assistant, Polytechnic Univ., 6 Metrotech Center,
Brooklyn, NY 11201.
3
Graduate Research Assistant, Polytechnic Univ., 6 Metrotech Center,
Brooklyn, NY 11201.
Note. Discussion open until August 1, 2002. Separate discussions
must be submitted for individual papers. To extend the closing date by
one month, a written request must be filed with the ASCE Managing
Editor. The manuscript for this paper was submitted for review and pos-
sible publication on December 11, 2000; approved on August 1, 2001.
This paper is part of the Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental
Engineering, Vol. 128, No. 3, March 1, 2002. ©ASCE, ISSN 1090-0241/
2002/3-262–273/$8.00+$.50 per page.
Fig. 1. Target grid viewed through 2-in.-thick layered transparent
soil model. The bottom three rows are viewed through amorphous
silica discussed in this paper and the middle 4.5 rows are viewed
through silica gel represents sand discussed in Sadek et al. 2002.
The top 2.5 rows are viewed through pore fluid.
262 / JOURNAL OF GEOTECHNICAL AND GEOENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING / MARCH 2002