News Coverage and Sales of Products with Trans Fat
Effects Before and After Changes in Federal Labeling Policy
Jeff Niederdeppe, PhD, Dominick L. Frosch, PhD
Introduction: The Food and Drug Administration mandated that food products list the amount of
trans fat per serving on nutrition facts labels by January 1, 2006. There have been no
coordinated efforts to raise awareness about trans fat since the policy went into effect,
but news coverage may promote informed decisions about food purchases. This paper
assesses whether news coverage influenced sales of products containing trans fat,
between December 13, 2004, and June 24, 2007, both before and after the labeling
policy went into effect.
Methods: Sales data for products containing trans fat from a major grocery store chain with stores
throughout Los Angeles County were merged with news coverage data from LexisNexis
®
and ProQuest. Cross-sectional time–series regression was conducted in 2008 to assess the
effect of news coverage on weekly unit sales volume for seven trans-fat products across
11,997 store-weeks.
Results: News coverage effects were apparent for sales of two of the seven trans-fat products in the
year before the trans-fat nutrition facts labeling policy went into effect (p0.05 with
Bonferroni correction). News coverage effects were observed for sales of six of the seven
trans-fat products in the post-labeling period (p0.05 with Bonferroni correction). For
most products, effects were strongest at concurrent and 1-week lags, and they dissipated
over time.
Conclusions: News coverage about trans fat, combined with labeling information, appears to influence
consumer behavior in the short term. News coverage and product labeling may not be
sufficient to promote sustained changes in trans-fat purchases.
(Am J Prev Med 2009;36(5):395– 401) © 2009 American Journal of Preventive Medicine
Introduction
T
he consumption of trans fatty acids (trans fat),
found in partially hydrogenated oils, is associ-
ated with substantially increased risk of coro-
nary heart disease (CHD).
1,2
Efforts to reduce trans-
fat consumption in the U.S. have used two
approaches. The first approach attempts to reduce
trans-fat levels in the food supply through legislation
that forces the food industry to replace trans fat with
more healthful liquid vegetable oils.
3,4
New York
City, Philadelphia, and California have banned the
use of trans fat in foods prepared in restaurants, and
several other states are considering similar laws.
5–7
The second approach, championed by the U.S.
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the US-
DHHS, attempts to reduce trans-fat consumption by
raising public awareness of its harmful effects. To this
end, the USDHHS 2005 Dietary Guidelines for Amer-
icans recommend that trans-fat consumption be “as
low as possible.”
2
The FDA mandated that the
amount of trans fat per serving be listed on the
nutrition facts label for all conventional foods and
dietary supplements.
8
Effective January 1, 2006, all
food products are required to list the amount of trans
fat if it exceeds 0.5g per serving.
Despite this apparent commitment to informed
decisions about diet, there is modest public knowl-
edge about the health effects of trans fat.
7,9,10
There
have been no coordinated efforts to raise awareness
about trans fat since the labeling policy went into
effect. A recent study concluded that nutrition facts
labels on foods are unlikely to produce informed
decisions about trans-fat purchases in the absence of
broader consumer education programs.
7
At the same time, many newsworthy events about
trans-fat research and policy have occurred. Tiburon
CA became the first trans fat–free city in the U.S. in
May 2005. January 2006 witnessed the final imple-
mentation of the FDA’s trans-fat labeling mandate. A
From the Department of Communication, Cornell University (Nie-
derdeppe), Ithaca, New York; and the Department of Medicine,
Division of General Internal Medicine and Health Services Research,
University of California Los Angeles (Frosch), Los Angeles, California
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Jeff Niederdeppe,
PhD, Assistant Professor, Department of Communication, 336
Kennedy Hall, Cornell University, Ithaca NY 14853-4203. E-mail:
jdn56@cornell.edu.
395 Am J Prev Med 2009;36(5) 0749-3797/09/$–see front matter
© 2009 American Journal of Preventive Medicine • Published by Elsevier Inc. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2009.01.023