Materials Science and Engineering A 493 (2008) 299–304
Environmental influence on interface interactions
and adhesion of Au/SiO
2
M.S. Kennedy
a
, N.R. Moody
b
, D.P. Adams
c
, M. Clift
b
, D.F. Bahr
a,∗
a
Washington State University, Pullman, WA, United States
b
Sandia National Laboratory Livermore, CA, United States
c
Sandia National Laboratory Albuquerque, NM, United States
Received 9 April 2007; received in revised form 27 August 2007; accepted 24 September 2007
Abstract
The mode I interfacial adhesion energy for as-deposited Au/SiO
2
was measured using a stressed overlayer test, and ranged from 0.39 ± 0.09 J/m
2
for spontaneous blisters to 0.37 ± 0.17 J/m
2
for indentation-induced blisters. After these films were heated to 100
◦
C and 300
◦
C for 1 h, the
interfacial fracture energies increased, to 0.9 J/m
2
and 9.9 J/m
2
, respectively. This was consistent with Au/SiO
2
films aged over an 8-year period,
which had a mode I interfacial fracture energy between 1.2 J/m
2
and 1.9 J/m
2
. The blister delamination was monitored over the course of over a
year, and exhibited growth after an initial stabilization period. Subsequent testing of delaminations with controlled humidity reproduced this growth
mechanism. Changes in interfacial adhesion energies are discussed in light of changes in interfacial chemistry and the exposure of an interfacial
crack tip to humidity.
© 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Adhesion; Humidity; Interface; Interfacial fracture energy
1. Introduction
For microelectronic components to be reliable, the delami-
nation of films needs to be eliminated over the predicted device
usage lifetime. A crack will propagate through an interface and
cause delamination when the strain energy of the system exceeds
the interfacial fracture energy (adhesion energy) of the interface.
To predict conditions under which propagation of a crack will
not occur, both the strain energy available in the system and the
critical interfacial fracture energy need to be known.
Typically, interfacial fracture energies reported in the liter-
ature have focused on as-deposited conditions. Depending on
the aging mechanisms of the film, however, these initial interfa-
cial fracture energies could have little relation to the interfacial
fracture energies seen during the life of the interface. Environ-
mental changes, such as temperature fluctuations and exposure
to humidity, can lead to diffusion of components materials or dif-
fusion of environmental species along the interface or through
the film. This can lead to less distinct interfaces, chemistry
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 509 335 8523; fax: +1 509 335 4662.
E-mail address: dbahr@wsu.edu (D.F. Bahr).
changes at the interface, the development of new phases, and
changes in applied stress from thermal expansion mismatch
between the film and substrate or the packaging.
Studies of metal–oxide systems have tried to define a critical
fracture energy for interfacial failure, which reflects the mechan-
ical and microstructural contributions of component materials
such as the strength and thickness of metal films and crack path
locations. Oh et al. noted that in service, the failure of micro-
electronic devices from interface fracture occurs more often by
subcritical cracking in the bond at stresses below those required
for catastrophic failure and that crack growth behavior along the
ceramic–metal interfaces is a major issue in the reliability and
long-term stability of these interfaces [1].
Deterioration of microelectronic systems is typically slow
and these systems can withstand anywhere from thousands to
millions of service hours before failure [2]. Recent work has
shown that the lifetimes of thin film systems can be shortened
with increased thermal cycling [3]. In addition, environmental
changes such as humidity are often not constant and can fluctuate
over time. In order to test systems, methods to accelerate indi-
vidual aspects of the aging process are needed. Once the specific
failure mechanisms due to environmental factors are pinpointed
and tested, researchers will be able to predict and ultimately
0921-5093/$ – see front matter © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.msea.2007.09.081