The Viability of Somaliland:
Internal Constraints and Regional
Geopolitics
Asteris Huliaras
Throughout the Cold War, secession was taboo in the state-centric international
system. However, the breakup of the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia,
the independence of Eritrea and East Timor as well as recent developments in
Kosovo seemed to weaken the principle of inviolable state boundaries. From one
point of view, these events may have far-reaching repercussions for Africa where
borders are generally considered to be more arbitrary than elsewhere (Herbst
1989). And no other area in Africa is closer to secession than the northern region
of Somalia — an area whose boundaries largely correspond to the former British
Protectorate of Somaliland. (The British and Italian colonies of Somaliland be-
came the Republic of Somalia in 1960.)
In 1991, the northern region of Somalia declared its independence from a state
that was collapsing into chaos. Thus, a regional administration (retaining the
name ‘Somaliland’) has in the last decade overseen the creation of a modest state
structure, a safe environment and a revitalised commercial economy. This con-
trasts sharply with the anarchy that characterises the south. However, Somaliland
has failed to achieve international recognition as a separate state.
This paper examines the viability of Somaliland as an independent entity by
analysing three important factors influencing the prospects for its continuing
existence and also attempts to define the success of its efforts for international
recognition: first, economic viability; secondly, the viability of its political insti-
tutions; and thirdly, the international environment, including the prospects for
reconstitution of political order in the southern part of Somalia.
Nation-Formation and the Declaration of Independence
The majority of the people of Somaliland have developed a sense of identity
distinct from the rest of Somalis; a sense of identity mainly based on kinship and
shared historical experiences. More specifically, four factors played a crucial role
in the formation of this identity.
Firstly, a distinct clan dominates the region: all Somalis belong to one ethnic group,
Journal of Contemporary African Studies, 20, 2, 2002
ISSN 0258-9001 print / ISSN 1469-9397 online/02/020157-26 © 2002 Journal of Contemporary African Studies
DOI: 10.1080 / 025890002200000515 1