Gender Diferences in College Students’ Behaviors
in an Online Quesion-answer Discussion Acivity
Shan-Shan Cheng
Naional Central University, Taiwan
Eric Zhi-Feng Liu*
Naional Central University, Taiwan
totem@cc.ncu.edu.tw
Nian-Shing Chen
Naional Sun Yat-sen University
Ru-Chu Shih
Naional Pingtung University of Science and Technology
Chiung-Sui Chang
Tamkang University, Taiwan
The Asia-Paciic Education Researcher 21:2 (2012), pp. 244-256
Copyright © 2012 De La Salle University, Philippines
Social cognitive theory emphasizes the relationship among personal (P), behavioral (B), and environmental (E) factors.
This study draws on the social cognitive perspective to examine the relationship among gender, learning performance, and
online behaviors in an online question-answer discussion activity. Online behaviors include the number of times a student
logs in, asks questions, and gives responses. Questions are classiied as either administrative, factual, comprehensive, or
integrated. A total of 105 junior college students majoring in Information Management (MIS) (48 female and 57 male
students) from northern Taiwan took a face-to-face General English Proiciency Test (GEPT) preparation course. The students
used a discussion forum to ask questions, answer questions, discuss related issues, and exchange learning information. The
results indicate that gender differences (P) resulted in different online discussion behaviors (B). In addition, the types of
question asked (E) by male and female students (P) were different. Based on the relationships found among these variables,
this study provides some suggestions to teachers for better facilitating learning in discussion forums.
Keywords: Computer-mediated communication; interactive learning environments; gender differences; improving online
learning
In online discussion forums, asking questions is an
essential learning activity. Some researchers believe asking
questions helps learners construct knowledge (Hou, Chang,
& Sung, 2008; King, 1994, 1995; Richardson, 1997), and
different types of questions will trigger different cognitive
activities among learners and yield various types of replies
from other learners (King, 1994, 1995). Toledo’s (2006)
research showed that good questions help students engage
in deep thinking and elicit responses that require deeper
thinking than mere factual answers.. She also suggested that
teachers have to provide models of good question-asking
techniques to students when leading online discussions
(Toledo, 2006). Although most people know that asking
questions drives thinking, little research systematically
investigates online question-answer discussion activities. To
help us better understand the relationships between online
discussion activities, learners’ characteristics, and learners’
online behaviors, this paper systematically investigates
students’ online question-answer discussion activities.
The perspective of social cognitive theory indicates
that an individual’s personal inluences (P), behaviors (B),
and social environment inluences (E) interact with one