Printed Fingerprints: A Framework and first results towards detection
of artificially printed latent fingerprints for forensics
Stefan Kiltz
a
, Mario Hildebrandt
a
, Jana Dittmann
a
, Claus Vielhauer
b
, Christian Kraetzer
a
a
Research Group on Multimedia and Security, Dept. of Computer Science, Otto-von-Guericke
University, PO Box 4120, 39016 Magdeburg, Germany;
b
Brandenburg University of Applied Sciences, PSF 2132, 14737 Brandenburg, Germany
ABSTRACT
In Schwarz
1
an amino acid model for printing latent fingerprints to porous surfaces is introduced, motivated by the need
for reproducibility tests of different development techniques for forensic investigations. However, this technique also
enables the fabrication of artificial traces constituting a possible threat to security, motivating a need for research of
appropriate detection techniques. In this paper a new framework for modelling the properties of a generic fingerprint
examination process is introduced. Based on the framework, examination properties and detection properties are derived
by a subjective evaluation. We suggest a first formalisation of exemplary properties, which can be easily extended to fit
different needs. We present a first experimental setup limited to two printers and the Schwarz amino acid model using
absorbing and non-absorbing material with first results to show tendencies and underline the necessity for further
research.
Keywords: Subjective quality evaluation, multimedia systems evaluations
1. MOTIVATION
In Schwarz
1
an amino acid model for printing latent fingerprints to porous surfaces is introduced. This is motivated by
the need for reproducibility during the assessment of different development techniques for forensic investigations. Those
amino acids are printed on paper in different concentrations by means of a HP bubble-jet ink-jet printer. This approach
can be used legitimately for quality assurance (according to
1
). Besides this aspect, with an increasing amount of
fingerprints addressed in today’s biometric authentication systems the miss-use of such a printing approach by enabling
the fabrication of artificial traces constitutes a possible threat to security (e.g. see constitutional complaint reported in
2008 by
10
). Thereby latent fingerprints (real, natural fingerprint patterns) can be captured without the knowledge of the
person concerned, e.g.
9
where a fingerprint is taken from a glass of water. Using the Schwarz amino acid model with
ink-jet printers the captured real, natural fingerprint pattern can be printed; enabling in theory the fabrication of traces of
everyone on a crime scene. Hence, the detectability of artificial traces is an upcoming necessity in forensics. In our paper
the following question is addressed: How to detect and distinguish between real, natural latent fingerprint patterns from
humans and artificially printed latent fingerprints under the consideration of the Schwarz amino acid model and bubble-
jet printing techniques (from
1
). The potentially relevant properties of existing printing technologies, fingerprint
properties and existing optical scan technologies are briefly described in section 2. Based on the findings of section 2 we
address the problem of detecting artificially printed latent fingerprints by suggesting a new framework for modelling the
properties of a generic fingerprint examination process in section 3. The framework formalises the examination as a
process chain composed of the fingerprint printing, processing of the physical forensic trace sample, digital acquisition
and a later subsequent subjective assessment of the digital sample. Based on this framework we experimentally study,
using the test setup described in section 4, which of the properties are significant for detection. For this purpose, we
present our first results from experiments in using samples from two different printers, which printed one fingerprint on
two different printing surfaces and optionally applied development techniques:
Using the Schwarz amino acid ink only,
Enhanced by the development technique ninhydrin or
Enhanced by the development technique carbon black powdering
Image Quality and System Performance VIII, edited by Susan P. Farnand, Frans Gaykema, Proc. of SPIE-IS&T Electronic
Imaging, SPIE Vol. 7867, 78670U · © 2011 SPIE-IS&T · CCC code: 0277-786X/11/$18 · doi: 10.1117/12.872329
SPIE-IS&T/ Vol. 7867 78670U-1