© The Author(s), 2010. Reprints and permissions:
http://www.sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
SAGE Publications, http://sdi.sagepub.com
Vol. 41(4): 347–367, DOI: 10.1177/0967010610374311
Sovereignty, Security, Psychiatry:
Liberation and the Failure of Mental Health
Governance in Iraq
ALISON HOWELL*
Humanitarian and Conflict Response Institute (HCRI),
University of Manchester, UK
This article examines how psychiatry has been used as a technology of
security in post-‘liberation’ Iraq. Drawing on Foucault and Foucauldian
work on the history and sociology of medicine, it begins by tracing
how, from the 19th century onwards, psychiatry has instantiated its
authority through a claim to provide social security within national
spaces, both through methods of sovereign confinement and through
liberation and governance. Arguing that the various ‘psy’ disciplines
– and medicine more generally – are increasingly used as technologies
of security internationally, the article examines psychiatric practice in
Iraq, where patients in the Al Rashad psychiatric institution were acci-
dentally liberated from their confinement by US Marines in 2003. Iraq’s
‘mentally ill’ were initially considered a manageable security threat
and thus subject to liberal community governance efforts. Yet, after
the so-called suicide bombing of two pet markets in 2008, reportedly
by former Al Rashad patients, those deemed ‘mentally ill’ and others
associated with them were once again made subject to sovereign con-
finement, marking a failure in liberal governance. Thus, this article
seeks to explore some of the complex lines connecting sovereignty,
security and psychiatry in post-‘liberation’ Iraq, and in global politics
more generally.
Keywords Iraq • psychiatry • medicalization • sovereignty •
governance
S
CHOLARS WORKING IN THE FIELD of the sociology of medicine have
long since probed how psychiatry and psychology have been deployed
as technologies of liberal governance aimed at providing social security
within national spaces. Yet, little has been said about how the various ‘psy’