Neuropsychological and Cognitive Performance of Homeless Adults
Graham Pluck and Kwang–Hyuk Lee
University of Sheffield
Rajan David
Sheffield Care Trust, Sheffield, United Kingdom
Sean A. Spence and Randolph W. Parks
University of Sheffield
Many homeless people may have been exposed to events and situations that could potentially produce
neuropsychological impairments. In the current study, 80 homeless participants underwent a battery of
tests designed to 1) estimate long-standing established memory and intelligence, which was assumed to
indicate prehomeless function and 2) measure current memory and intelligence function. Mental health
screening and substance misuse data were also obtained. Results indicated that current memory and IQ
were significantly lower than the estimated normal population means and also their prehomeless
estimates. The memory score change was from 100.5 to 90.3 ( p .001) and IQ change from 98.8 to 95.6
( p = .038). The interaction between task type (memory or IQ) and measure (prehomeless or current) was
also significant ( p = .003), signifying that there was a greater change in the domain of memory function
than in IQ. Many participants reported substance misuse and clinically significant mental health
concerns. We conclude that the homeless individuals in our sample appear to have suffered a reduction
in cognitive function, which may have occurred either during homelessness or prior to it.
Keywords: cognition, homelessness, intelligence, IQ, memory, premorbid
Homelessness presents a range of challenges to those govern-
mental and nongovernmental agencies that occasionally or rou-
tinely deal with vulnerable and insecurely housed individuals.
These include health services, social care providers, governmental
benefit agencies, and charities. It has been estimated that within
the European Union around 2.7 million people can be defined as
homeless (i.e., either literally roofless, in inappropriate housing, or
living in overcrowded conditions; Avramov, 1999). When the
definition of homelessness is limited to those who are literally
roofless, living in temporary shelters or squats, it has been esti-
mated that there are around 85,000 homeless individuals in the
United Kingdom (U.K.; Kenway & Palmer, 2003), with compa-
rable figures of 35,000 in Canada and 350,000 in the United States.
(Murphy, 2000). Indeed, homelessness has emerged as a major
social concern in most developed countries (Toro, 2007).
There are multiple societal and economic factors that influence
the level of homelessness, including access to affordable housing,
national stability, societal wealth, and local welfare provision
(Berger & Tremblay, 1999). However, there are also likely to be
multiple intrapersonal factors. Homeless individuals tend to dis-
play personality profiles characterised by pessimism and a nega-
tive perspective on the past (Pluck et al., 2008) and to report high
levels of traumatic events in their childhoods (Pluck et al., 2011;
Spence et al., 2006). It is, perhaps then, not surprising that many
homeless people display complex psychosocial problems that ap-
pear to predate their homelessness and often remain after rehous-
ing (Vostanis, Grattan, & Cumella, 1998).
In addition, systematic literature reviews of cognitive function
in children and adolescents (Parks, Stevens, & Spence, 2007) and
adults (Backer & Howard, 2007; Burra, Stergiopoulos, & Rourke,
2009; Spence, Stevens, & Parks, 2004) have described high levels
of cognitive impairment in samples of homeless individuals. Many
homeless people may be at the lower range of cognitive abilities
and this may have contributed to their difficulties within society.
This could be due to childhood socioeconomic disadvantage, poor
family functioning, and inadequate access to education. For exam-
ple, a homeless sample in the United States was found to have
notably poor reading ability (Solliday–McRoy, Campbell,
Melchert, Young, & Cisler, 2004). In another study of neuropsy-
chological test performance in homeless individuals in the United
States, it was found that education level was the only statistically
significant demographic factor, accounting for 29% of the variance
(Gonzalez, Dieter, Natale, & Tanner, 2001).
Alternatively, it is feasible that many homeless people have
suffered a decline in cognitive function as a consequence of
homelessness. In support of this suggestion, homelessness is as-
sociated with a range of factors with the potential to impair
cognition, including poor nutrition (Evans, 1996), raised levels of
substance misuse (Pluck, Lee, & Parks, 2007), and mental illness
Graham Pluck, Kwang–Hyuk Lee, Sean A. Spence, and Randolph W.
Parks, Academic Clinical Psychiatry, University of Sheffield, Sheffield,
United Kingdom; Rajan David, Homeless Assessment and Support Team,
Sheffield Care Trust, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
Randolph W. Parks is now at the Choate Mental Health Center, Illinois
Depatement of Human Services, in Anna, Illinois, USA. We regret the
death of Sean A. Spence during the final stages of this project.
This research was supported by a grant from the Sheffield Health and
Social Research Consortium. We thank David Coldwell for being a
homeless-service user consultant to the project.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Dr.
Graham Pluck, Academic Clinical Psychiatry, University of Sheffield, The
Longley Centre, Norwood Grange Drive S5 7JT, United Kingdom. E-mail:
g.pluck@sheffield.ac.uk
Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science © 2011 Canadian Psychological Association
2011, Vol. ●●, No. ●, 000–000 0008-400X/11/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0025382
1