Published by Maney Publishing (c) W. S. Maney & Son Limited
A media pandemic: Influenza A in
Portuguese newspapers Correspondence to:
Felisbela Lopes,
Communication and
Society Research Centre –
University of Minho,
Campus de Gualtar,
4710-057 Braga,
Portugal
felisbela@ics.uminho.pt
Felisbela Lopes, Teresa Ruão, Sandra Marinho, Rita Araújo
Communication and Society Research Centre –
University of Minho, Braga, Portugal
Abstract
On April 2009, the World Health Organization
declared a global pandemic alert as a consequence
of the appearance of a new influenza virus, named
‘Influenza A, H1N1’. In Portugal, media coverage
on this disease was intense. However, as the
number of deaths within Influenza A patients
turned out to be much lower than the foreseen stat-
istics of national authorities, the hypothesis of a
‘media pandemic’ was suggested by national
opinion makers. Looking for a better understanding
of the phenomenon, we conducted a study on
media coverage and news sources on Influenza A
in Portugal. The study of news sources on health
issues is a way of understanding health information
and it has been a neglected area on Health
Communication. This investigation stood on the
examination of 655 articles of three national news-
papers, with distinct editorial criteria. The analysis
considered six variables: number of sources, geo-
graphic location, genre, identification, status, and
medical expertise. This task followed a quantitative
methodology. The findings confirmed previous
noticed trends on health information research: the
power of official sources, the complexity of access
to medical sources, and the lasting misunderstand-
ings between journalists and the medical
community.
Keywords: Health communication, Influenza A,
Newspapers
Introduction
At the beginning of 2009, the media around the
world began alerting populations for the risk of an
influenza pandemic. The first reports on this
subject emerged in March and they referred the
appearance of a new influenza virus in Mexico. In
April, the World Health Organization (WHO) offi-
cially recognized this disease and named it as
Influenza A, H1N1, for its identification with the
common flu (known as type A) and with a particu-
lar subtype (the H1N1).
The new virus had genes of the human, avian,
and swine variant, but it presented an all new com-
bination, never observed anywhere before. Hence,
specialists soon began stressing the dangers of the
new flu to humans, due to its high risk of contagion
and unpredictable evolution. Accordingly, the
WHO declared that Influenza A was an international
public health emergency and announced a pandemic
alert on April (which in July had already reached
maximum levels, in a risk scale of 1–6; Portuguese
National Board of Health-DGS, alerta@dgs.pt, 29
June 2009). The possibility of a pandemic and its
consequences to the world population made this a
priority matter to every country’s public health
authorities.
Given this possibility, the world media soon began
to reproduce these concerns expressed by the WHO
and the national states. According to the Gapminder
Foundation (http://www.gapminder.org/videos/
swine-flu-alert-news-death-ratio-tuberculosis/), from
April to May 2009 it was already possible to
count on Google more than 250 000 news on
Influenza A.
In Portugal, the media also followed the disease’s
evolution intensively. Reports of the Portuguese
news coverage (Marketest, in http://www.marktest.
com) point out that from 24 to 28 April 2009 the
national televisions broadcasted 130 news related to
Influenza A, filling 14% of the TV information. In
the end of 2009, the numbers had already reached
1897 TV news.
This level of newsworthiness is uncommon in
health journalism and somehow expresses the high
informative value given to this matter by national
media. However, this degree of importance soon
began being questioned by opinion makers, given
that the worst predictions about the epidemic
ended up failing to meet expectations throughout
2009. In July, the Portuguese National Board of
Health (DGS) reported that the pandemic could
19
© W.S. Maney & Son Ltd 2012
DOI: 10.1179/2047971911Y.0000000001 International Journal of Healthcare Management 2012 VOL. 5 NO. 1