Muhd Hafizi Idris, Member, IEEE, Mohd Saufi Ahmad, Ahmad Zaidi Abdullah, Surya Hardi
School of Electrical System Engineering
Universiti Malaysia Perlis,
Arau, Perlis, Malaysia.
Abstract-- This paper describes an adaptive distance relaying
scheme which can eliminate the effect of fault resistance on
distance relay zone reach. Distance relay is commonly used as
main protection to protect transmission line from any type of
fault. For a stand-alone distance relay, fault resistance can make
Mho type distance relay to be under reached and thus the fault
will be isolated at a longer time. In this scheme, the relay detects
the fault location using a two-terminal algorithm. By knowing
fault location, fault voltage at the fault point can be calculated by
using equivalent sequence network connection as seen from local
terminal. Then, fault resistance is calculated by using simple
equation considering contribution from remote terminal current.
Finally, the compensation of fault resistance is done onto
calculated apparent resistance as seen at relaying point. The
modeling and simulation was carried out using Matlab/Simulink
software. Several cases were carried out and the results show the
validity of the scheme.
Index Terms—Distance relay, Fault location, Fault resistance,
Matlab/Simulink, Mho type, Single line to ground
I. INTRODUCTION
ransmission line is one of the main components in High
Voltage (HV) and Extra High Voltage (EHV) power
system. The protection of transmission line from any type of
fault is very important because any mis-operation or mal-
operation of protection relays can give a great effect on the
stability of power system entirely. One of the main protection
used to protect transmission line is distance or impedance
relay. It uses the impedance measurement technique to
measure the apparent impedance as seen by the relay at the
relaying point. The inputs for distance relay are three phase
current and voltage phasors during fault occurrence.
Transmission line is segregated into several zones of
protection normally zone 1, zone 2 and zone 3 as shown in
Fig. 1 for relay at substation A [1]. Distance relay acts as main
protection for faults within zone 1 while for zone 2 and zone
3, it acts as backup protection for adjacent line.
Fig. 1. Zones of protection for distance relay
Zone 1 reach is normally set only up to 80% - 90% of the
protected line. It is not set 100% of the protected line to avoid
relay from under reached or over reached due to current and
voltage measurement errors, transient effect and inaccuracy in
transmission line parameters. If a fault occurred within this
zone where distance relay acts as main protection, the relay
will instantaneously send trip signal to open the circuit
breaker.
To ensure full coverage of the protected line by considering
errors and other effects, zone 2 is set at minimum 120% of the
protected line. It is a common practice to set zone 2 reach
equal to 100% of the protected line plus 50% of the shortest
adjacent line. For faults within zone 2 reach, tripping signal
will be sent at a delayed time where the relay acts as backup
for main protection at adjacent line. The tripping time for zone
2 normally set at several hundred miliseconds.
Backup protection for entire adjacent line is covered by
zone 3 reach. It is normally set at least 1.2 times the
impedance of protected adjacent line. The set tripping time for
zone 3 reach is typically several seconds.
An accurate apparent impedance measurement during fault
occurrence by distance relay is very important because false
measurement might result in delayed tripping signal sent by
distance relay. There are several factors which can lead to
inaccurate apparent impedance measurement such as high
fault resistance, mutual inductance of parallel line, line
charging capacitance and transient effects due to switching of
Flexible Alternating Current Transmission System (FACTS)
devices [2]-[6].
In this paper, focus is given to compensate the effect of
fault resistance on the accuracy of Mho type distance relay.
Fault resistance can be high or low depending on the nature of
fault. Even a small fault resistance value can make the relay to
be under reached when it is used to protect short transmission
line. The relay also might be under reached when the fault is
near to remote substation terminal. Delayed tripping of circuit
breaker due to under reached of distance relay will make the
power system in stress for a longer time.
II. THEORIES OF THE PROPOSED SCHEME
This section presents the methodologies used to
compensate the effect of fault resistance on the accuracy of
apparent impedance measurement. The process began with
determining the fault location during the occurrence of fault.
There are many techniques currently and previously used to
Adaptive Mho Type Distance Relaying Scheme
with Fault Resistance Compensation
T
2013 IEEE 7th International Power Engineering and Optimization Conference (PEOCO2013), Langkawi, Malaysia. 3-4 June 2013
208
978-1-4673-5074-7/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE