Silver Nanowire Networks as Flexible,
Transparent, Conducting Films:
Extremely High DC to Optical
Conductivity Ratios
Sukanta De,
†,‡
Thomas M. Higgins,
§
Philip E. Lyons,
†,‡
Evelyn M. Doherty,
†,‡
Peter N. Nirmalraj,
‡,
Werner J. Blau,
†,‡
John J. Boland,
‡,
and Jonathan N. Coleman
†,‡,
*
†
School of Physics, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland,
‡
Centre for Research on Adaptive Nanostructures and Nanodevices, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland,
§
School of Chemistry, University of Wollongong, Wollongong NSW 2522 Australia, and
School of Chemistry, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland
T
hin, transparent, conducting films
are critical for many optoelectronic
devices and components. They are
most heavily used for electrode applications
in devices such as liquid crystal, flat panel
or plasma displays, touch panels, organic
light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), and solar
cells but are also commonly used as anti-
static coatings and EMI shielding material.
Such films are usually made from doped
metal oxides, most commonly indium tin
oxide (ITO). However, ITO has a number of
drawbacks and is unlikely to be the material
of choice in future optoelectronic devices.
The difficulties with ITO revolve around the
rising cost of indium, the brittleness of ITO,
and the high temperature processing used
in its production. Attempts to resolve the
first problem have involved use of alterna-
tive metal oxides,
1,2
thin metal films,
3,4
or
metal grids
5,6
to prepare transparent con-
ductors. However, the latter two problems
are probably more significant; future dis-
plays will be larger and will probably reside
on a plastic rather than a glass substrate
and so must be flexible. Thus, prospective
displays will require flexible transparent
electrodes that can be produced at low
temperature and over large areas at low
cost. We note that such requirements are
in addition to traditional technical require-
ments associated with low sheet resistance
and high transparency.
It has been known for the past few years
that flexibility and low temperature pro-
cessing can be achieved by deposition of
nanostructured thin films from the liquid
phase. These are known to be stable under
flexing
7
and can be spray cast,
8
opening the
way to large area deposition. While poly-
mer
9
and graphene
10-15
films have been
studied, the most common material used
to date has been carbon nanotubes.
7,8,16-27
While the cost associated with nanotubes is
still a factor, it is expected to come down
as demand increases to industrial levels.
However, the main problem has been
achieving transmittance and sheet resis-
tance values routinely achievable with ITO.
It is straightforward to achieve sheet resis-
tance of 10 /▫ for transmittance of
90% with ITO. Such values have not been
achieved with nanostructured electrodes. A
commonly used figure of merit for transpar-
ent conductors is the ratio of DC to optical
conductivity,
DC
/
Op
. To achieve R
s
= 10
/▫ and T = 90% requires
DC
/
Op
= 350
*Address correspondence to
colemaj@tcd.ie.
Received for review April 6, 2009
and accepted June 11, 2009.
Published online June 24, 2009.
10.1021/nn900348c CCC: $40.75
© 2009 American Chemical Society
ABSTRACT We have used aqueous dispersions of silver nanowires to prepare thin, flexible, transparent,
conducting films. The nanowires are of length and diameter close to 6.5 m and 85 nm, respectively. At low
thickness, the films consist of networks but appear to become bulk-like for mean film thicknesses above 160
nm. These films can be very transparent with optical transmittance reaching as high as 92% for low thickness. The
transmittance (550 nm) decreases with increasing thickness, consistent with an optical conductivity of 6472 S/m.
The films are also very uniform; the transmittance varies spatially by typically <2%. The sheet resistance decreases
with increasing thickness, falling below 1 /▫ for thicknesses above 300 nm. The DC conductivity increases
from 2 10
5
S/m for very thin films before saturating at 5 10
6
S/m for thicker films. Similarly, the ratio of DC
to optical conductivity increases with increasing thickness from 25 for the thinnest films, saturating at 500 for
thicknesses above 160 nm. We believe this is the highest conductivity ratio ever observed for nanostructured
films and is matched only by doped metal oxide films. These nanowire films are electromechanically very robust,
with all but the thinnest films showing no change in sheet resistance when flexed over >1000 cycles. Such results
make these films ideal as replacements for indium tin oxide as transparent electrodes. We have prepared films
with optical transmittance and sheet resistance of 85% and 13 /▫, respectively. This is very close to that
displayed by commercially available indium tin oxide.
KEYWORDS: nanowires · electrode · flexible · transparent · conducting
ARTICLE
www.acsnano.org VOL. 3 ▪ NO. 7 ▪ 1767–1774 ▪ 2009 1767