The American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 2013; 39(1): 33–37
Copyright © Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.
ISSN: 0095-2990 print/1097-9891 online
DOI: 10.3109/00952990.2012.702172
The Relationship between Wisdom and Abstinence Behaviors in Women
in Recovery from Substance Abuse
Julia A. DiGangi, M.S., M.A.
1
, Leonard A. Jason, Ph.D.
1
, Leslie Mendoza, B.A.
1
,
Steve A. Miller, Ph.D.
2
, and Richard Contreras, Ph.D.
1
1
Center for Community Research, DePaul University, Chicago, IL, USA,
2
Department of Psychology, Argosy University,
Chicago, IL, USA
Background and aims: Wisdom is theorized to be an
important construct in recovery from substance abuse.
In order to explore the role of wisdom in substance abuse
recovery behaviors, the present study had two goals.
First, it sought to examine the factor structure of a
wisdom scale, the Foundational Value Scale (FVS) in a
community sample of women in recovery from
substance abuse. Second, the study examined how
wisdom predicted the women’s beliefs about their ability
to abstain from future substance use. Methods: 116
women in recovery from substance abuse disorders were
recruited from self-run recovery homes and a substance
abuse recovery convention. Results: Results from an
exploratory factor analysis indicated that a modified
version of the FVS has good internal consistency
reliability and is composed of three wisdom-related
dimensions. The three factors were then used to create a
higher-order wisdom factor in a structural equation
model (SEM) that was used to predict abstinence self-
efficacy behaviors. Results from the SEM showed that
the wisdom factor was predictive of greater abstinence
self-efficacy behaviors. Conclusion: The FVS was found
to be a reliable measure with women in recovery from
substance abuse. In addition, wisdom predicted beliefs
about self-efficacy such that those who reported higher
levels of wisdom felt more confident in their abilities to
abstain from alcohol. Scientific significance: The results
of this study indicate that wisdom is an important
construct in the abstinence behaviors of women who are
in recovery from substance abuse disorders.
Keywords: wisdom, substance abuse, women, exploratory factor
analysis
INTRODUCTION
Although the study of wisdom is complex due to its multi-
faceted nature, previous research suggests some core com-
ponents of what people deem wisdom. Specifically, while
associated with acquired knowledge, wisdom is generally
recognized to encompass more than just intelligence (1).
Wisdom appears to be defined as a form of knowledge
linked primarily to an awareness of, and connection
to, oneself, one’s surroundings, and others (2–5).
Additionally, wisdom has been demonstrated to encom-
pass a type of intelligence generated from experience (6).
Others have expanded wisdom’s definition to include
aspects of spirituality and connectedness to nature (2,7).
Wisdom is theorized to be an important construct for
understanding substance use disorder (SUD) recovery.
For example, wisdom is integral to the organizing frame-
work of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) and Narcotics
Anonymous (NA). The 12-step meetings are based – not
on empirical research or the judgment of clinicians – but on
wisdom accumulated through the lived and shared experi-
ences of recovering addicts (8). Similarly, the Serenity
Prayer – which it is read at many AA and NA meetings –
calls on individuals to recognize the things they can
change, the things they cannot change, and the wisdom
to know the difference. Twelve-step practices, like the
Serenity Prayer, might be a form of wisdom that helps
individuals better manage their lives through reflection
and personal insights. Much of this wisdom may be linked
to spiritual practices of 12-step programs. Findings from a
recent study suggest that AA leads to better sobriety out-
comes, in part, by enhancing individuals’ spiritual prac-
tices and providing support for AA’s own emphasis on
increasing spiritual practices to facilitate recovery from
alcohol use disorder (9). Twelve-step programs endorse
reliance on a “Higher Power” and encourage the use of
prayer and meditation (10). In fact, the main purported
mechanism of recovery from “alcoholism” is identified
as a “spiritual awakening” (10) or “spiritual experience”
(10). Although wisdom and spirituality are related, they are
not synonymous construct and, at present, little is known
about the specific role of wisdom in the context of 12-step
participation. At present, only one study examined the
relationship between wisdom and alcohol use. In that
study, Perry and colleagues (11) examined problem
Address correspondence to Julia A. DiGangi, Center for Community Research, DePaul University, 990 W. Fullerton Ave., Suite 3100, Chicago,
IL 60614, USA. E-mail: jdigangi@depaul.edu
33
Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Governors State University on 02/13/13
For personal use only.