0012-4966/01/0102- $25.00 © 2001 MAIK “Nauka / Interperiodica” 0086
Doklady Biological Sciences, Vol. 376, 2001, pp. 86–88. Translated from Doklady Akademii Nauk, Vol. 376, No. 5, 2001, pp. 707–709.
Original Russian Text Copyright © 2001 by Borkin, Litvinchuk, Milto, Rosanov, Khalturin.
The system of modern speciation states that species
are genetically isolated population systems, although
limited interspecies hybridization is possible in contact
zones. Therefore, in population-genetic terms, species
are determined by the level of reproductive, i.e.,
genetic, isolation rather than the degree of morpholog-
ical and other differences. Striking evidence for this
postulate is provided by the existence of the so-called
twin species, i.e., the species that are almost indistin-
guishable in appearance but obviously isolated geneti-
cally [1]. Naturally, such species, also called cryptic
(“hidden”), can only be identified by nonmorphological
characteristics, such as differences in ecology, behav-
ior, cytogenetics, or biochemistry. To date, twin species
have been found in many groups of animals, including
amphibians. In Europe, e.g., they were described for
salamanders of the genus Hydromantes and in tailless
amphibians of the genera Alytes, Discoglossus, Hyla,
and Rana [2–7]. The occurrence (and, accordingly, fre-
quency of finding) of twin species can form ideas of
biodiversity whose preservation is now a priority. It is
obvious that a reliable estimation of actual biodiversity
is impossible without modern cytogenetic and molecu-
lar methods. Twin species should occur most frequently
in common widespread species, which live under dif-
ferent ecological conditions and, hence, should be
genetically diverse. Many species of amphibians in
Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union do have
such vast ranges traversing different climatic and land-
scape zones.
In the course of long-term studies on the interspe-
cies variability of the genome size in amphibians, we
revealed two population types of the spade-footed toad
Pelobates fuscus (Laurenti, 1768) from the family
Pelobatidae differing in the DNA content. This species
of tailless amphibians is typical of Europe; it is wide-
spread from France to northern Kazakhstan. This spe-
cies is common in many areas and has never attracted
special interest from taxonomists. Except for northern
Italy, inhabited by the isolated subspecies P. f. insubri-
cus, the remaining enormous area of the species range
is considered to be inhabited by the nominative subspe-
cies, P. f. fuscus [8, 9].
In 1986–1999, we studied 143 animals from 25
P. f. fuscus populations in Russia, Latvia, Ukraine, and
Moldova, using DNA flow cytometry [10] (figure).
Peripheral blood of the brown frog Rana temporaria
(Rt) was used as a reference sample. The size of its
genome was assumed to be 1.0. According to the
genome size, all the samples appeared to break down
into two geographic groups with significantly different
amounts of nuclear DNA. In the “eastern” group of
spade-footed toads, the average genome size was 0.826
(0.811 to 0.842) Rt, whereas in the “western” group of
spade-footed toads, it was only 0.782 (between 0.770
and 0.797) Rt. Thus, the variation ranges for these
groups did not even overlap; the mean values differed
by about 5.6%. In absolute units corrected for the
genome size of the mouse Mus musculus (6.8 pg), the
amount of nuclear DNA is 9.32 (9.17 to 9.43) pg in the
“eastern” group and 8.84 (8.74 to 8.93) pg in the “west-
ern” group.
The “eastern” spade-footed toads were found in the
Volga Region (Udmurtia and Nizhny Novgorod oblast),
in the chernozem regions of Russia (Belgorod, Voron-
ezh, and Tambov oblasts) and Ukraine (Kharkov
oblast), as well as in central European Russia (Penza
and Ryazan oblasts). Smaller spade-footed toads with a
smaller genome were found in Latvia, Moldova,
Ukraine (Odessa and Chernigov oblasts), as well as
northwestern (Pskov and Yaroslavl oblasts) and central
European parts of Russia (Tula oblast).
It is obvious that these differences are not acciden-
tal, since the region of the study covered a substantial
part of Eastern Europe from the Baltic Sea to the
Danube delta and the Volga, and the geographic distri-
butions of the “larger” and “smaller” genomes fit a cer-
tain pattern instead of being chaotic. Moreover, the dif-
ferences between the “eastern” and “western” types
were stable and reproducible when we analyzed the
samples in different years.
Cryptic Speciation in Pelobates fuscus (Amphibia, Pelobatidae):
Cytometric and Biochemical Evidence
L. J. Borkin*, S. N. Litvinchuk**, K. D. Milto*, J. M. Rosanov**, and M. D. Khalturin**
Presented by Academician N.N. Nikol’skii March 20, 2000
Received April 19, 2000
* Zoological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences,
Universitetskaya nab. 1, St. Petersburg, 199034 Russia
** Institute of Cytology, Russian Academy of Sciences,
Tikhoretskii pr. 4, St. Petersburg, 194064 Russia
GENERAL BIOLOGY