Change detection and di¡erence detection of
tone duration discrimination
Shuntaro Okazaki
a
, Shin’ichiro Kanoh
b
, Kana Takaura
a
, Minoru Tsukada
c
and Kotaro Oka
a
a
School of Fundamental Science and Technology, Graduate School of Science and Technology, Keio University, Kanagawa, Japan,
b
Department of Electronic
Engineering, Graduate School of Engineering, Tohoku University, Miyagi, Japan and
c
Faculty of Engineering, Tamagawa University, Tokyo, Japan
Correspondence and requests for reprints to Shuntaro Okazaki, School of Fundamental Science and Technology, Graduate School of Keio University,
3-14 -1 Hiyoshi, Kohoku-ku, Yokohama 223- 8522, Japan
Tel: + 81 45 5631151 ext. 42345; fax: + 81 45 564 5095; e-mail:okazaki@bpni.bio.keio.ac.jp
Sponsorship: This work was supported by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, Grant-in-Aid for 21st century COE
program ‘Understanding and Control of Life’s Function via Systems Biology’.
Received 11 January 2006; accepted13 January 2006
An event-related potential called mismatch negativity is known
to exhibit physiological evidence of sensory memory. Mismatch
negativity is believed to represent complicated neuronal mechan-
isms in a variety of animals and in humans. We employed the
auditory oddball paradigm varying sound durations and observed
two types of duration mismatch negativity in anesthetized guinea
pigs. One was a duration mismatch negativity whose increase in
peak amplitude occurred immediately after onset of the stimulus
di¡erence in a decrement oddball paradigm. The other exhibited a
peak amplitude increase closer to the o¡set of the longer stimulus
in an increment oddball paradigm. These results demonstrated a
mechanism to percept the di¡erence of duration change and
revealed the importance of the end of a stimulus for this
perception. NeuroReport 17:395^399 c 2006 Lippincott
Williams & Wilkins.
Keywords: auditory perception, discrimination, event-related potentials, guinea pigs, mismatch negativity
Introduction
The perception of sound duration change is one of the most
primitive brain functions required for survival. To investi-
gate this type of perception, a sequence of repetitive
frequent (standard) stimuli and infrequent (deviant) stimuli
(the oddball paradigm) was employed and elicits an event-
related potential (ERP) that is called mismatch negativity
(MMN) [1]. MMN is observed not only in humans [2–5], but
also in many awake and anesthetized mammals, for
example, monkey [6], cat [7,8], rabbit [9], mouse [10], and
guinea pig [11,12]. To clarify the neuronal mechanisms of
MMN, it is important to establish animal models of the
brain response involved in MMN. In fact, the research of
animal models has contributed significantly to the under-
standing of the neuronal mechanisms of human MMN.
Auditory MMN is elicited by a deviance of the stimuli in
various physical attributes such as duration, intensity, and
frequency of simple tones [13], or of more complex stimuli
[14]. Recent studies indicate that auditory MMN is involved
in higher-order speech processing (i.e. temporal auditory
grouping and speech sound perception [14–17]). Thus,
MMN is believed to provide an index of higher order
function in auditory processing.
Furthermore, it is well known that the amplitude and
latency of MMN change depend on the different frequencies
of standard and deviant stimuli [18]. Therefore, MMN appears
to indicate the brain’s detection of how a difference magnitude
between standard and deviant stimuli is (difference detection),
in addition to the detection of the stimulus change (change
detection). Studies, for example, [19,20] have reported how the
difference magnitude of duration change may be represented
in MMN and its magnetic counterpart (MMNm). Studies
investigating the difference between duration increment and
decrement, however, do not exist. Previous studies have
reported that duration MMN is triggered by the onset of the
stimulus difference (OSD) [10]. On the oddball paradigm in
which the duration of the deviant stimuli is shorter than that
of the standard stimuli (duration decrement oddball para-
digm), the difference of duration between the standard and
deviant stimuli is recognized at the OSD. In the duration
increment oddball paradigm, difference of duration between
standard and deviant stimuli, however, is detected at the offset
of deviant stimuli as opposed to the OSD.
Noting the different timing of the change detection and
the difference detection in duration discrimination, we
investigated the event-related potential from varying dura-
tions (duration MMN) on anesthetized guinea pigs. In this
study, the amplitude and latency of the duration MMN
varied according to the direction of the tone duration
change (duration increment and decrement). As the guinea
pig is an inexpensive and easily available laboratory animal
with good audition [21] and its anatomical and electro-
physiological attributes are remarkably established, it is an
ideal subject for our research. This animal model of MMN
has good applicability for future studies on neuronal
mechanisms of duration discrimination in humans.
AUDITORYAND VESTIBULAR SYSTEMS NEUROREPORT
0959-4965 c Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Vol 17 No 4 20 March 2006 395
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.