Communication
Theory
148
Research Beyond the Pale:
Whiteness in Audience Studies
and Media Ethnography
This article examines the role of whiteness as a structuring absence to ethno-
graphic audience research. After ignoring whiteness altogether, media ethnog-
raphers have tended to essentialize whiteness within narratives of structural
dominance or individual vulnerability. Using poststructuralist theories of lan-
guage, whiteness, and hegemony, the author argues that these narratives for
whiteness can be traced to experiences in the field that are shaped by historical
and institutional forces outside of the field. Researchers both perform white-
ness in the field, by claiming its privilege and hiding its visibility, and codify
whiteness for others to identify outside the field. To illustrate, the author exam-
ines “narcissistic whiteness” and “defensive whiteness” as two articulations
that are visible in her own field notes, interpreted through unifying narratives
and rearticulated through an alternative reading of the notes.
Despite long-standing and repeated calls for self-reflexivity in the ethno-
graphic study of audiences, there has been little theoretical attention to
how self-reflection occurs. Specifically, where and when does the eth-
nographer construct the “self” in relation to the audiences under study?
We can see the manifest results of self-reflexive research in written ac-
counts. In this article, I explore the latent aspects of a self-reflexive pro-
cess, that is, the potential accounts of the self that do not appear in the
ways we write ourselves into the work. By exploring one dimension of
self-reflexivity—the articulation of whiteness in media audience re-
search—I hope to identify spaces and times where self-reflection may
occur in “fields of power,” to borrow Pierre Bourdieu’s phrase, and the
process by which ethnographers then construct narratives of self that are
powerful but incomplete in order to serve the reproduction of hegemony.
Whiteness is an excellent place to begin this theoretical process be-
cause, historically, it has been the structuring absence to the articula-
Vicki Mayer
Copyright © 2005 International Communication Association
Communication
Theory
Fifteen:
Two
May
2005
Pages
148–167