Colonisation, Globalisation, and the Future of
Languages in the Twenty-first Century
*
SALIKOKO S. MUFWENE
University of Chicago
The typical academic discourse on language endangerment has
presented languages as anthropomorphic organisms with lives
independent of their speakers and capable of negotiating on their own
the terms of their coexistence. Not surprisingly it has become
commonplace to read about killer languages in the same vein as
language wars, language murders and linguicides. I argue below that
languages are parasitic species whose vitality depends on the
communicative behaviours of their speakers, who in turn respond
adaptively to changes in their socio-economic ecologies. Language
shift, attrition, endangerment and death are all consequences of these
adaptations. We must develop a better understanding of the ways in
which one ecology differs from another and how these dissimilarities
can account for variation in the vitality of individual languages.
Globalisation is discussed as part of the relevant language ecology. I
submit that only local globalisation has endangered or driven most
languages to extinction.
his article is a general critique of the literature of the past decade on language
endangerment, including the following recent major works, which are
typically not cited individually here except for peculiarities that warrant singling
out any one of them: Mühlhäusler (1996), Dixon (1997), Brenzinger (1998),
Grenoble and Whaley (1998), Calvet (1998), Crystal (2000), Fishman (2000),
Hagège (2000), Nettle and Romaine (2000), Maffi (2001) and Renard (2001). I
exhort linguists to embed the subject matter in a historical perspective longer than
European colonisation of the past 400 years, to highlight the competition and
T
International Journal on Multicultural Societies (IJMS), Vol. 4, No. 2, 2002: 162 - 193
ISSN 1817-4574, www.unesco.org/shs/ijms © UNESCO
*
This article has largely developed from my contribution to a debate with Professor Claude Hagège,
under the title Quel avenir pour les langues?, at UNESCO Headquarters in Paris on 19 September
2001 (part of the series Entretiens sur le XXIe siècle). The original French title was Colonisation,
mondialisation, globalisation et l’avenir des langues au XXIe siècle, from which mondialisation has
now been omitted, for reasons that soon become obvious in the text. The essay has also benefited
from lectures I gave on 7 November and 3 December 2001 at, respectively, the National University
of Singapore and Hong Kong University entitled “Colonization, globalization, and language
endangerment”. I am equally indebted to Michel DeGraff, Claude Hagège, Alison Irvine, Paul
Newman and my anonymous referees for comments on earlier drafts of this publication.