Copyright © 2007 by the author(s). Published here under license by the Resilience Alliance.
Deconchat, M., A. Gibon, A. Cabanettes, G. du Bus de Warnaffe, M. Hewison, E. Garine, A. Gavaland, J.-
P. Lacombe, S. Ladet, C. Monteil, A. Ouin, J.-P. Sarthou, A. Sourdril, and G. Balent. 2007. How to set up a
research framework to analyze social–ecological interactive processes in a rural landscape. Ecology and
Society 12(1): 15. [online] URL: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol12/iss1/art15/
Research
How to Set Up a Research Framework to Analyze Social–Ecological
Interactive Processes in a Rural Landscape
Marc Deconchat
1
, Annick Gibon
1
, Alain Cabanettes
1
, Gaétan du Bus de Warnaffe
1
, Mark Hewison
2
,
Eric Garine
3
, André Gavaland
1
, Jean-Paul Lacombe
1
, Sylvie Ladet
1
, Claude Monteil
1
, Annie Ouin
1
,
Jean-Pierre Sarthou
1
, Anne Sourdril
1
, and Gérard Balent
1
ABSTRACT. Interdisciplinary research frameworks can be useful in providing answers to the
environmental challenges facing rural environments, but concrete implementation of them remains
empirical and requires better control. We present our practical experience of an interdisciplinary research
project dealing with non-industrial private forestry in rural landscapes. The theoretical background,
management, and methodological aspects, as well as results of the project, are presented in order to identify
practical key factors that may influence its outcomes. Landscape ecology plays a central role in organizing
the project. The efforts allocated for communication between scientists from different disciplines must be
clearly stated in order to earn reciprocal trust. Sharing the same nested sampling areas, common approaches,
and analytical tools (GIS) is important, but has to be balanced by autonomy for actual implementation of
field work and data analysis in a modular and evolving framework. Data sets are at the heart of the
collaboration and GIS is necessary to ensure their long-term management and sharing. The experience
acquired from practical development of such projects should be shared more often in networks of teams
to compare their behavior and identify common rules of functioning.
Key Words: fragmented forest; interdisciplinary research; landscape ecology
INTRODUCTION
The close links between human activities and
environmental processes call into question our
collective ability to identify, within the complex
functioning of social systems, what impact human
activities have on ecological phenomena and to
propose operational responses to manage them
(Southwood 1995, Legay 2006). Rural areas are
facing rapid changes and uncertainty in the
agricultural and forestry fields that affect their
future (Deffontaines et al. 1995). Finding effective
answers to such issues is hampered by the difficulty
in designing functional research frameworks to deal
with such large and fuzzy questions (Sébillote
2001). Because they are both social and ecological
in nature, these questions must be approached using
an interdisciplinary framework that provides an
integrative view (Holling 1998, 2001) of the
reciprocal interactions between the two systems
(Jollivet 1992, Boiffin 2004). However, creating
interdisciplinary research frameworks is not simply
a matter of juxtaposing disciplines, nor of forcing a
continuous interaction—and even less that of an
illusory combination—but rather one of developing
a dynamic and specific operating mode for research
(Delattre 1985). Defining rules to build and manage
such interdisciplinary research frameworks better,
faster, and more effectively represents, in its own
right, a useful quest to respond to current
environmental challenges.
We believe that a method to set up an
interdisciplinary research framework must be
developed from a theoretical analysis of how
research is conducted, dealing with questions of
scales and models (Holling 2001), but also taking
into consideration the practical constraints that
strongly shape current research activities and yet
have received less interest. We aim to identify some
key practical factors for more efficiently setting up
an interdisciplinary research project dealing with
1
UMR1201 Dynamiques Forestières dans l'Espace Rural, INRA, INPT-ENSAT,
2
UR35 Centre d’Ecologie de la Faune Sauvage, INRA,
3
UMR7535
Laboratoire d’Ethnologie et de Sociologie Comparative, CNRS