PRESSURE DROP OPTIMISATION IN DESIGN OF MULTI-STREAM PLATE-FIN HEAT
EXCHANGERS,CONSIDERING VARIABLE PHYSICAL PROPERTIES
Nassim Tahouni,
1
* Samira Miryahyaie,
1
Fatemeh Joda,
1
Hamid Reza Fallahi
2
and Mohammad Hassan
Panjeshahi
1
1. School of Chemical Engineering, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2. Petro Hitech Co., Tehran, Iran
A modified method for the design of multi-stream plate-fin heat exchangers that considers variable physical properties is proposed in this paper.
The new method, based on Pinch Technology, exploits the dependency of physical properties (heat capacity, viscosity, density and thermal
conductivity) on temperature variations. A set of temperature correction factors based on variable physical properties is derived for the hot and
cold streams of a multi-stream heat exchanger. This allows calculation of effective stream pressure drops, which can lead to a valid trade-off
between operating and capital cost in the targeting stage. Accordingly, composite curves are constructed; based on the enthalpy intervals, the
multi-stream heat exchanger is subdivided into a number of block sections. A plate-fin heat exchanger is then designed for each section by
maximising the allowable effective pressure drops. Next, using a Genetic Algorithm, the method is completed in order to optimise the pressure
drop of streams. Therefore, fin types for each individual stream are considered as optimising variables. By taking the variable physical properties
of each stream into account and using the best fin selection, one can achieve accurate results in the design stage.
Keywords: multi-stream plate-fin heat exchangers, pinch technology, genetic algorithm, pressure drop optimisation, variable physical properties
INTRODUCTION
A
considerable portion of total plant cost is consumed by
heat exchangers, which has motivated designers to find
a method to optimally transfer heat. Because of their
remarkable ability to exchange heat between more than two
streams simultaneously, in addition to certain environmental and
investment considerations, multi-stream plate-fin heat exchang-
ers have been the focus of several publications. The large heat
transfer areas, which are needed on both fluid sides of the com-
pact heat exchanger, are satisfied by adding secondary surfaces.
Examples of secondary surfaces are plain fins, strip fins and lou-
vered fins. The fins extend the heat transfer surfaces and promote
turbulence.
[1]
Because heat exchangers cover an extremely wide range of
applications, many design methods have been suggested over
the years. Pinch Technology is a conceptual method commonly
adopted for the analysis of heat exchanger networks. Picon-
Nunez et al.
[2]
extended this technique for multi-stream plate-fin
heat exchangers using the temperature versus enthalpy diagrams
known as composite curves. In their approach, maximising the
allowable pressure drop of the critical streams in each interval is
observed as a design objective; however, under this specification
the optimal results are not necessarily obtained.
Additionally, according to some sensitivity analysis carried out
in different experimental works,
[3,4]
it is important to make the
results more realistic when considering the variation of physical
properties and their effects on pressure drop. Estimation of phys-
ical properties in small temperature intervals using MATLAB and
HYSYS software is a method used by Ghannadi et al.,
[5]
but cal-
culation is difficult. In contrast, Fallahi
[6]
proposed a new method
in the targeting and design of heat exchanger networks that led to
reliable and accurate results in a short time with the introduction
of temperature correction factors for both sides of shell-and-tube
heat exchangers.
In this paper, by extending Fallahi’s method, a new temperature
correction factor () for plate-fin heat exchangers is derived for use
in the design of multi-stream heat exchangers. The application of
this new method is then investigated in a case study.
In recent years, many methods have been proposed for the opti-
misation of heat exchangers; in these methods, various parameters
are evaluated to achieve optimal results. Combining the Simulated
Annealing algorithm and Pinch Technology principles, Panjeshahi
et al.
[7]
presented a new method for designing multi-stream heat
exchangers based on optimum pressure drops. Using a Neural
Network, Peng and Ling
[8]
described hydraulic and thermal spec-
ifications for five types of fins that could be used to find the
minimum weight and total annual cost of a multi-stream heat
exchanger. A methodology was developed by Ghosh et al.
[9]
to
determine the optimal staking pattern using a Genetic Algorithm;
in this methodology, two methods of area splitting and succes-
sive partitioning were used. However, ignoring the variation of
physical properties leads to wrong results. Searching through 52
fin types to adopt the appropriate one for each stream is the
focus of this paper. To achieve optimum pressure drops, a modi-
fied method for determining the best fin type for each stream is
developed based on Pinch Technology principles using the Genetic
Algorithm. Because of the offsets that variations in physical prop-
erties have upon pressure drop and the heat transfer coefficient
of the streams, it is crucial to consider the physical properties
of the streams as variable parameters. In this effort, the optimi-
sation algorithm considers the temperature correction factors for
∗
Author to whom correspondence may be addressed.
E-mail address: ntahuni@ut.ac.ir
Can. J. Chem. Eng. 9999:1–10, 2013
©
2013 Canadian Society for Chemical Engineering
DOI 10.1002/cjce.21781
Published online in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com).
| VOLUME 9999, 2013 | | THE CANADIAN JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING | 1 |