© by PSP Volume 21 – No 4. 2012 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
844
SINGLE AND JOINT EFFECTS OF PERCHLORATES TO
DAPHNIA MAGNA: ADDITIVITY AND INTERACTION PATTERNS
Susana Loureiro
1,
*, Tayvia L. Meyer
1
, Abel L. G. Ferreira
1
, Mónica J. B. Amorim
1
and Amadeu M. V. M. Soares
1
1
Department of Biology & CESAM, University of Aveiro, 3810-193 Aveiro, Portugal.
ABSTRACT
Frequent cases of soil and water contamination by
perchlorates, and consequent toxicity to plants, animals and
humans have drawn attention worldwide. Anthropogenic
actions are the main cause for this pollution. Due to high
levels of oxidation, perchlorates are commonly used to
produce solid propellants for rockets and missiles, fire-
works, and air bag inflators and also as bleach in paper
industry. In this work we assessed the effects of ammo-
nium and sodium perchlorates singly and in mixture to
Daphnia magna by studying the endpoints: immobiliza-
tion, reproduction, growth and feeding activities.
At short time exposures characterized with immobili-
zation and feeding parameters, ammonium perchlorate
was 10 times more toxic to D. magna than sodium per-
chlorate. On the other hand, toxicity was similar when a
long-term exposure with reproduction parameter was
carried out. The mixture toxicity approach also showed that
sodium perchlorate was ruled for synergistic patterns when
dominant in the short-term exposure tests. When evaluating
the reproductive effort by using the number of neonates,
the concentration addition model was the best fit.
This study shows that the different properties of two
chemicals, highlighting the possible synergy that can occur
when chemicals are present in mixtures, will be of high re-
levance to improve Cumulative Risks assessment proce-
dures.
KEYWORDS: Perchlorates; mixture; synergism, acute toxicity;
chronic toxicity; Daphnia magna.
1. INTRODUCTION
Mixture toxicity and multiple stresses is one of the
considerable areas where risk assessment of chemicals
should and has been considerably improved. The shift
from a single-compound to a cumulative approach has
consequences for the assessment of exposure, effects and
* Corresponding author
risks. In addition, new techniques for chemical detection
lead to the acknowledgement of new threats to the envi-
ronment and human health [1, 2]. Perchlorates (ClO
-4
) have
become of environmental concern after being found in
several water supplies in 1997, in the United States of
America [2]. They had been detected in groundwater,
drinking water, soils and vegetation and were found in
places with routinely use of explosives, solid propellants,
rockets, missiles and fireworks, wastewater and industrial
discharge or urban runoff, and are known to be also re-
leased to the environment by research laboratories and
fertilizers [1-3]. The Massachusetts Public Water Supplies
detected in 2005 perchlorate concentrations ranging from
783 – 1300 µg/L, in a condominium nearby a bedrock
aquifer, possibly due to blasting activities (http://www.
mass.gov/dep/cleanup/sites/percsour.pdf). In Europe, little
information is available on perchlorates in the environ-
ment, however perchlorate concentrations of 0.8 mg/L
were recorded in soil leachates collected from an oak-
hornbeam forest, in northeast Vernun (France, in addition
to heavy metals and chlorates (71 mg/L) [4].
Although some data about the ecotoxicological effects
of perchlorates was reported for the zebra fish (Danio
rerio) [5], the frog Rana sphenocephala [6], the fish Gos-
terosteus aculeatus [7], or the molly fish Poecilia sphenops
[8], effects on invertebrates have not been widely studied.
The survival and reproductive success of earthworms [9]
and the acute and chronic toxicity of the larval mosquito
Culex quinquefasciatus [10] are examples of what have
been described.
Perchlorate salts often appear associated with other
(per)chlorates or chemicals and therefore their joint toxic-
ity is a key factor to be studied in addition to single
chemical toxicity.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the combined
effects of ammonium and sodium perchlorates using
Daphnia magna as a model organism. To achieve this goal,
a first approach to detect toxicity patterns of their single
toxicity was carried out. This information will be used as
crucial foundations for the combined experiments, since
prediction and modelling of mixture toxicity is based on
single toxicities.