234 ECOLOGICAL MANAGEMENT & RESTORATION VOL 7 NO 3 DECEMBER 2006 © 2006 Ecological Society of Australia
NOTES &
ABSTRACTS
GENETIC ISSUES & SOLUTIONS
18.2
Molecular markers detect multiple origins of Agonis
flexuosa (Myrtaceae) plants used in urban bushland
restoration. Elizabeth A. Sinclair,
1
John D. Bussell,
2
Siegfried L. Krauss,
3
Richard Hobbs,
4
and Kingsley W.
Dixon
3
(
1
School of Environmental Science, Murdoch
University, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia, and Botanic
Gardens and Parks Authority, Fraser Ave, West Perth, WA
6005 Australia;
2
ARC Centre of Excellence in Plant Energy
Biology, The University of Western Australia, Crawley,
Western Australia, 6009, Australia;
3
Botanic Gardens and
Parks Authority, Fraser Ave, West Perth, Western Australia,
6005, Australia, and School of Plant Biology, The University
of Western Australia, Crawley, Western Australia, 6009,
Australia;
4
School of Environmental Science, Murdoch
University, Murdoch, WA 6150, Australia.
Email: esinclair@iinet.net.au).
Key words: AFLP, Agonis flexuosa, genetic marker, plant
source, revegetation.
Introduction. Conservation issues faced by urban bushland
managers include habitat loss and degradation associated
with urban expansion, and substantial reductions to the
range and abundance of many species. Habitat fragmentation
commonly increases bushland susceptibility to deterioration
in species diversity, composition and ecosystem processes,
and provides increased opportunities for the invasion of
weedy species. Consequently, urban bushland areas often
require some form of intervention. In highly degraded sites
where additional planting may be required, the selection
of plant material becomes an issue, as poor choice for
(introduced) source material may compromise the long-
term genetic integrity of the local native populations.
The principle of using local seed in native plant restoration /
rehabilitation activities is widely regarded as best-practice
by the restoration industry, and is currently specified by
Natural Heritage Trust (NHT), regional natural resource
management organizations, Greening Australia, local bush
management groups, and all levels of government
(Mortlock 2000; Sackville Hamilton 2001; Carr 2005). Poor
sourcing of material may potentially result in failure of
restoration efforts, loss of biodiversity, and/or poor integra-
tion with the remaining native vegetation. Identification of
appropriate seed-source populations is important, particu-
larly in Western Australia where population genetic differ-
entiation within species is often pronounced (Coates 2000).
The greatest limitation to the application of the principle of
using local seed is in the identification of the extent of what
is local (Mortlock 2000), and this will vary on a species-by-
species basis. In this context, molecular markers can deter-
mine population genetic structure, and more specifically in
the case described here, assist in the identification of non-
local plants used in a previous restoration effort.
Peppermint tree (Agonis flexuosa Willd.) is a common
and widespread species, typically found in the coastal
dunes and limestone areas of the south-west corner of
Western Australia between Perth and Albany. It has a fairly
continuous coastal distribution; however, native popula-
tions are rare and highly fragmented in the Perth metro-
politan area (northern most extent of its range). This species
is also a favoured plant for urban gardens and street verges,
making differentiation between native and non-native
populations difficult at some locations. The Peppermint
Tree is a relatively long-lived, perennial species that can
grow as a tree or in mallee form. Here, we generate DNA
fingerprints to estimate the genetic relationship between
three natural occurrences of the species including one at
Bold Park, a 437-ha native bushland remnant in the western
suburbs of Perth, as well as an occurrence of specimens
apparently planted in a restoration zone at Bold Park
approximately 20 years ago.
Methods. Leaf samples were sampled from a total of 38
plants from three native bushland sites: Dawesville (32′37′′S
115′38′′E; n = 12), Preston Beach Road (32′54′′S 115′42′′E;
n = 11), and Bold Park (31′57′′S 115′45′′E; n = 15). The
collection sites outside Bold Park were the nearest native
populations seen as potential seed sources; locations where
replanting had occurred were avoided. Within Bold Park,
another 46 plants were sampled from a rehabilitated area
north of the native plants. Local Bold Park plants were
clearly identifiable as large, multistemmed (mallee-like)
trees, whereas the apparently planted trees were young,
small, and most were single stemmed. Collected material
was kept fresh at 4°C until DNA extraction.
DNA was extracted using a modified cethyltrimethyl
ammonium bromide (CTAB) procedure (He et al. 2004).
Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) DNA
fingerprints (Vos et al. 1995) were generated for each
sample using fluorescently labelled primers (primer combi-
nations were M-CTA/E-ACT, M-CTA/E-AGG, M-CAG/E-ACC)
and an ABI PRSIM 377 automated sequencer, as described
previously (Krauss 1999), except that restriction digests and
ligations were performed in half the stated volume.
AFLP fragments between 60 and 500 bp were scored for
presence (1) or absence (0) for each sample with the aid of
ABI PRISM software. A principle coordinate
analysis (PCA) was performed in (Peakall &
Smouse 2001) to visually represent the relative degree of
genetic similarity among individuals and the distinction, if
any, among sampling locations. Pairwise Fisher’s exact tests
(Raymond & Rousset 1995) were performed to statistically
assess the significance of genetic differentiation between
pairs of sampling locations using the program Tools For
Population Genetic Analysis (, & Miller 1997);