Race, Genomics, Identities and
Politics in Contemporary Brazil
Ricardo Ventura Santos
Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública/Fundação Oswaldo Cruz and
Museu Nacional/Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Marcos Chor Maio
Casa de Oswaldo Cruz/ Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Brazil
Abstract The ‘new genetics’ (or genomics) has penetrated overwhelmingly into
a broad range of domains in the contemporar y world, spawning a technocultural
revolution in relation to genes that has transformed technologies, institutions,
practices and ideologies. The ‘new genetics’ has not only reshaped the
biological, cultural and social loci in the immediate surroundings of individuals,
but also reconfigures wide-ranging macro-social, historical and political
relations. In this article we approach the technocultural revolution surrounding
the ‘new genetics’ by means of a case study on the overlapping of race, genomics,
identities and politics in Brazil. We analyze how the ‘new genetics’ extends far
beyond the biological dimension to become an arena for dispute in which
historical, social and political elements are present. Specifically, we will analyze
the debate over the results of a survey that aimed to shed light on the ‘genetic
origins of Brazilians’ based on the sequencing of parts of mitochondrial DNA
and the Y chromosome. By focusing on how this survey was received, we will
explore some of the new, intense and abundant forms of relations between
‘nature/genetics’ and ‘culture/society’, in which DNA appears as an outstand-
ing player in the dispute between modalities for interpreting and transforming
social and political realities.
Keywords anthropology of science Brazil ethnicity genomics history of
science race
Introduction
The ‘new genetics’ (or genomics) has penetrated overwhelmingly into a
broad range of domains in the contemporar y world, spawning a techno-
cultural revolution in relation to genes that has transformed technologies,
institutions, practices and ideologies (Brodwin, 2002; Lindee et al., 2003;
Rabinow, 1992). As highlighted by Lindee et al. (2003: 14), ‘genetics in
practice is plastic and contingent, embedded deeply in culture, time, and
place’. The ‘new genetics’ not only reshapes the biological, cultural and
social loci in the immediate surroundings of individuals, but also
Article
Vol 24(4) 347–378 [DOI:10.1177/0308275X04047841]
Copyright 2004 © SAGE Publications (London, Thousand Oaks, CA
and New Delhi) www.sagepublications.com