Note
Do Protective Behaviors Follow the Experience of Testing
Positive for Herpes Simplex Type 2?
RICHARD A. CROSBY, PHD,* SARA HEAD, MPH,† RALPH J. DICLEMENTE, PHD,† BETH MEYERSON, PHD,‡
AND ADEWALE TROUTMAN, MD§
Objective: To test the hypothesis that individuals attending a sexu-
ally transmitted disease (STD) clinic would adopt sexual protective
behaviors after receiving a positive test for herpes simplex virus 2
(HSV-2).
Methods: Recruitment (N 360) occurred in a publicly funded
STD clinic located in a metropolitan area of the southern United
States. Participants were tested for HSV-2 using a rapid test manu-
factured by Biokit (Lexington, MA) and they completed a self-admin-
istered questionnaire before and 3 months after being tested for
HSV-2. Follow-up questionnaires were completed by 256 participants
(71.1%).
Results: Of those completing follow-up, 43.4% (n 111) tested
positive for HSV-2 at enrollment. Significant differences between par-
ticipants testing positive and those testing negative (at baseline) for
HSV-2 over the follow-up period were not observed for frequency of
sex, frequency of condom use, avoiding sex, and number of sex part-
ners. Controlling for statistically identified covariates did not alter the
null findings for these between group analyses. When analyzing change
(baseline to follow-up) among only those testing positive, significant
differences were not found with the exception of reporting greater
frequency of condom use with steady (P 0.037) and nonsteady
partners at follow-up (P 0.017). However, repeated measures anal-
yses yielded only 1 significant group time interaction; this indicated
a greater increase in condom use frequency with steady partners
among persons testing negative compared with those testing positive.
Conclusions: Among STD clinic attendees, diagnosis of HSV-2 was
unrelated to the adoption of sexual behaviors protective against fur-
ther acquisition and transmission of STDs. In the absence of education
beyond posttest counseling, becoming aware of HSV-2 positive serosta-
tus may not be sufficient to motivate the adoption of safer sex behav-
iors among this population.
IN THE UNITED STATES, herpes simplex virus 2 (HSV-2)
remains the primary cause of genital herpes and prevalence is
estimated at 17%.
1
HSV-2 is associated with neonatal herpes and
transmission of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).
2,3
The ad-
vent of type-specific rapid testing for HSV-2 has led to research
investigating psychosocial sequelae of testing positive, with results
indicating only short-lived consequences.
4–8
The next question is
whether persons newly diagnosed with HSV-2 will adopt behav-
iors protective against further acquisition and transmission of
sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). Literature investigating be-
havior change after HIV counseling and testing has led to variable
and inconclusive results.
9 –12
The most recent review found re-
duced risky sexual behavior after HIV counseling and testing
among persons newly diagnosed with HIV but not among persons
testing negative for HIV.
12
Although recent evidence suggests that
people are less likely to acquire HSV-2 from partners who disclose
their positive status,
13
disclosure may not be normative in all
populations. An important, but understudied, question is whether
patients may engage in risk management after diagnosis with
HSV-2 (meaning they adopt protective behaviors in response to
the diagnosis). Accordingly, the purpose of this study was to
determine whether protective behaviors follow the experience of
testing positive for HSV-2.
Methods
Study Sample
Patients (18 years old) were recruited from an STD clinic
located in the southern United States. Nurses referred potentially
eligible patients to the research assistant. Eligibility requirements
were 1) not previously diagnosed with HSV-2; 2) speaking En-
glish; 3) sexually active in the past 3 months; and 4) willingness to
be tested for HSV-2. Of 381 patients referred, 360 (94.5%) were
eligible, agreed to participate, and provided written informed con-
The authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance of the Clinic Director
(Deborah Snow) and the clinic staff members.
Supported by Glaxo Smith-Kline (to R.A.C).
Correspondence: Richard Crosby, PhD, College of Public Health, 121
Washington Avenue, Lexington, KY 40506-0003. E-mail: crosby@uky.
edu.
Received for publication October 10, 2007, and accepted March 16,
2008.
From the *Department of Health Behavior, University of Kentucky
College of Public Health, Lexington, Kentucky; †Department of
Behavioral Science and Health Education, Rollins School of Public
Health, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia; ‡Policy Resource
Group, LLC Indianapolis, Indiana; and §Louisville Metropolitan
Health Department, Louisville, Kentucky
Sexually Transmitted Diseases, September 2008, Vol. 35, No. 9, p.787–790
DOI: 10.1097/OLQ.0b013e318177a068
Copyright © 2008, American Sexually Transmitted Diseases Association
All rights reserved.
787