Flying high above the social radar:
Coronal stop deletion in modern Appalachia
K IRK H AZEN
West Virginia University
ABSTRACT
In this paper I examine how a classic feature of variationist research, coronal stop
deletion (CSD), operates at the end of the 20th century in one of the most
renowned vernacular dialects in the United States, English in Appalachia. Through
examination of CSD in a corpus of Appalachian speech, this paper also focuses on
the methodological choices available. Several methodological questions are
reviewed, such as the choices concerning voicing of the codas (wind vs. went vs.
west). The corpus comprises interviews with 67 Appalachian speakers, yielding
17,694 tokens of potential CSD. These were analyzed using quantitative
variationist methodology to reveal that morphological categories are less influential
than even the preceding phonological environment. This finding is in stark contrast
with some other vernacular varieties and suggests that apparent morphological
influences are actually phonological influences that present themselves as
morphological trends. Overall, the following phonological environment is
overwhelmingly the most influential linguistic factor on the rate of CSD. These
Appalachian speakers maintain relatively high rates, in effect constraining the
social distinctions within Appalachia that could possibly be made using CSD, but
marking them as vernacular speakers for those outside Appalachia.
In general, we will find that consonant cluster simplification is a phonological process
which intersects with grammatical processes, operating on a number of surface
formatives to produce highly reduced surface forms, and the general rule which
governs simplification can only be written when these grammatical forms are
accurately known. —Labov, Cohen, Robins, & Lewis (1968:124)
What was once seen as a vernacular feature of African American Vernacular
English (AAVE) has now been investigated as a common feature in varieties of
English around the world. As Schneider (2004:1126) summarized, deleting the
final consonant of a consonant cluster “is the norm in the Caribbean, in ethnic
dialects and contact forms in Am[erican] E[nglish], in L[iberean] S[ettler]
The author greatly appreciates the National Science Foundation for supporting this research (BCS-
0743489). The author would like to thank the research assistants of the West Virginia Dialect Project
for their work with this project, especially Paige Butcher, Sarah Vacovsky, Jaime Wagner, Ashley
King, Erin Simmons, Courey DeGeorge, Kyle Vass, and Elizabeth Spinelli. The author would also
like to thank Ralph Fasold and Walt Wolfram for their comments on consonant clusters.
105
Language Variation and Change, 23 (2011), 105–137.
© Cambridge University Press, 2011 0954-3945/11 $16.00
doi:10.1017/S0954394510000220