Obstacles and Opportunities in Women School Leadership:
A Literature Study
Vuyisile Msila
PO Box 392, University of South Africa, College of Education, UNISA 0003,
South Africa
E-mail: msilavt@unisa.ac.za
KEYWORDS Women Leadership. Glass Ceiling. Gender Stereotypes. Leadership Styles
ABSTRACT This article examines what literature says about women leadership in schools. A number of researchers opine that
the teaching profession has many women in its fold. However, there are few women leaders in educational institutions. In South
Africa there has been a conscious effort to address the past imbalances by (among others), ensuring that women are employed
in positions of educational leadership and management. This article looks at literature that discusses the various aspects of
gender and school leadership. Although the researcher focuses on South Africa, arguments here are of a universal nature. The
claims show that generally, the women in leadership theme, is becoming topical in many countries. There are many women
who are beginning to overcome the social stereotypes that underscore that women cannot succeed in leading organisations.
Many well-run schools in South Africa today have women at the helm. Exploring theories like Simone de Beauvoir’s, the
article also examines aspects such as the glass-ceiling effect as well as various leadership styles. It concludes by showing that
leadership differences between men and women are very minimal despite the society’s stereotypes and often misguided
pronouncements.
INTRODUCTION
Generally, the quantity of women employees
has been increasing in many countries around
the world although their numbers in manage-
ment positions remain disproportionately low
(Adler 1993). Coleman (2005: 3) concurs when
she pronounces, “internationally, the teaching
profession tends to be numerically dominated
by women, but in most countries, women do not
occupy a commensurate proportion of senior
leadership and management roles”. There are
several reasons for this and among these is that
for many decades people have associated lead-
ership traits to maleness. Over the years studies
have been showing that the society in general,
expected effective leaders to be male. Powell and
Graves (2003) cite Schein who hypothesized that
because a huge number of managers have been
males, the managerial job would be regarded as
requiring attributes thought to be more charac-
teristic of men than women. Furthermore, to
support her thesis, she discovered that both male
and female middle managers believed that a
successful middle manager possessed traits of
men than women. Whilst many will argue that
the status of women in workplace is gradually
changing, it is doing so at a sluggish pace: some-
times even women have internalised that they
are not ready for leadership and management
jobs.
In a recent study, Msila (2010) asked 70 male
teachers and 70 female teachers whether they
would take up school principalship if they were
offered. Fifty- three male teachers felt they would
while only 29 females out of the 70 maintained
that they would. This might have nothing to do
with the women’s ability to lead, but more to do
with the way society views them. Arguably, the
societal gender experiences have made women
to internalise that they are not made for leader-
ship; that leadership belongs to a man’s world.
Maybe some have seen how the male world has
“plotted” the demise of a few women leaders.
Therefore, while there is a gradual change to-
day, women leaders are still far from achieving
equality in the workplace (Stead and Elliott
2009). This conceptual paper utilises a review
of literature as it explores the complexities of
women in school leadership. The literature re-
viewed sheds light on aspects such as De
Beauvoir’s theory, the glass ceiling effect, lead-
ership styles and other barriers to women lead-
ership. This topic is universal although the au-
thor frequently refers to the South African situ-
ation. As a starting point, the focus below is on
what research says about women and school
leadership in South Africa.
FEMALE SCHOOL LEADERS:
A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE SOUTH
AFRICAN SITUATION
Current research in South Africa still reflects
that there are many women in teaching although
the adage that declares, “Women teach and men
© Kamla-Raj 2013 Int J Edu Sci, 5(4): 463-470 (2013)