Improving the effectiveness of business process development through
collaboration engineering: a method for process elicitation
Kalle Piirainen, Kalle Elfvengren, Jukka Korpela, Markku Tuominen
Lappeenranta University of Technology
Department of Industrial Management
P.O. Box 20
FIN-53851 Lappeenranta
Finland
{kalle.piirainen|kalle.elfvengren|jukka.korpela|markku.tuominen}@lut.fi
Abstract
Businesses transform and processes are
transformed as organizations adapt to a changing
business environment. The discipline of business
process reengineering has proposed guidelines for this
transformation, but the task is still challenging and the
risk of failure remains high. Especially group work
presents major challenges for process design..
Accordingly, this paper proposes a group support
system to support process development. The paper
leverages the collaboration engineering framework in
designing an artifact to support teamwork in process
elicitation. The artifact has been designed at a
conceptual level and validated through a business case
in a global process industry organization. The case
indicates that the method for process elicitation works
as intended in the given context. The contribution is a
group process for business process development.
1. Introduction
Business processes transform and are transformed
as organizations adapt to changing situations.
Traditional manufacturing companies have been forced
to move with the changing environment, which has
resulted in a need of tools for business process
development. Process management is a natural choice
for a management framework for many manufacturing
companies, as organizations are accustomed to viewing
their actions as processes from manufacturing to
management. The general idea is to make management
interventions repeatable, but what happens if the
system breaks down and the processes do not behave in
the intended manner? The apparent answer is process
development, more commonly called business process
reengineering.
Business process reengineering (BPR) has been a
popular tool for the management for some years. The
mission of BPR discipline is to offer tools for business
development through identification and transform of
workflows and processes. BPR consists of radically
transforming organizational processes through the
optimal use of information technologies to achieve
major improvements in quality, performance, and
productivity [10] [17]. The literature on the subject is
broad, including general discussion, practical advice,
and frameworks. Some reviews have not been very
favorable, e.g. [24], and many projects have not been
successful for various reasons, including lacking
planning and execution of BPR activities.
The real-world problem specific to this paper is that
a manufacturing company has experienced problems in
a business process despite some efforts of improving
the process. The company is facing challenges with the
demand forecasting process. Forecasting accuracy is in
a constant focus for improvement and the tools used
for supporting the process are being developed to
satisfy the user needs more comprehensively. The
requirements for the quality of the outcome of the
forecasting process are high, as the outcome is used as
input to other business-critical processes, like capacity
management. What makes the situation peculiar, is that
the process performance remains sub-par even though
some effort has been put into improving demand
forecasting. Thus, the first step before making further
attempts to improve the process is to gather data about
the demands, experiences and problems from the
stakeholders in the process. The case is the demand
forecasting process of a process industry company.
The main research problem in this paper is to
develop a method to engage various stakeholders in a
process development or process engineering workshop.
The literature review conducted to form the artifact
revealed that the existing literature leaves room for
Proceedings of the 42nd Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2009
1 978-0-7695-3450-3/09 $25.00 © 2009 IEEE