Journal of Management and Governance 3: 137–160, 1999.
© 1999 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
137
The Role of Knowledge Bases in Complex Product
Systems: Some Empirical Evidence from the Aero
Engine Industry
MASSIMO PAOLI
1
and ANDREA PRENCIPE
2
1
Università ‘G. D’Annunzio’, Pescara, Italy and SSSUP, Pisa, Italy;
2
CoPS Innovation Centre,
Sussex University, UK
Abstract. In this paper we argue that the virtual corporation as understood in current management
literature does not hold as a universal model throughout various industrial sectors. Complex product
systems industries show peculiar features in terms of product characteristics, innovation dynamics
and strategic and management options that may render the virtual corporation model inapplicable.
The paper begins with a contrast between the simplistic neoclassical approach to the interpreta-
tion of the concept of knowledge and the more in-depth evolutionary view. The former understands
knowledge as information and its production process and outcomes as easily decomposable. Based
on this, advocates of virtual corporation claim the viability of outsourcing strategies based on simple
economic factors. The evolutionary approach, on the other hand, considers knowledge as a system
of processes deeply rooted in their contexts of production. Tacitness and non-decomposability of the
knowledge production processes are highly emphasised in this view. In the light of this contrast and
relying on a study of the aero engine industry we reinterpret the notion of virtual corporation showing
its limits.
Key words: knowledge, processes, systems, complex products, aero-engine industry, systems inte-
grator
1. Introduction
In this paper we argue that the virtual corporation as understood in current manage-
ment literature does not hold as a universal model throughout various industrial
sectors. Complex product systems industries show peculiar features in terms
of product characteristics, innovation dynamics, and strategic and management
options that may render the virtual corporation model inapplicable.
The paper begins with a contrast between the simplistic neoclassical approach
to the interpretation of the concept of knowledge and the deeper evolutionary view.
The former understands knowledge as information and its production process and
its outcomes as easily decomposable. Based on this, advocates of virtual corpora-
tion claim the viability of outsourcing strategies based on simple economic factors.
The evolutionary approach, on the other hand, considers knowledge as a system
of processes deeply rooted in their contexts of production. Tacitness and non-