Chapter 1
From empty spaces to lived
lives
Exploring the individual in the
Palaeolithic
Clive Gamble and Martin Porr
Introduction
For too long the Palaeolithic was regarded by archaeologists as the most
un-promising of all periods for the reconstruction of society and economy
(e.g. Childe 1951; Wheeler 1954). However, in the past fifty years it has been
demonstrated that this widespread impression has no basis either in the
supposed lack of evidence or in its quality. Well-preserved, high-resolution
sites are known from all periods and regions of the Palaeolithic world (e.g. Carr
1984; Conard 2001b; Cziesla et al. 1990; Gamble and Boismier 1991; Goring-
Morris 1987; Hietala 1984; Kind 1985; Kroll and Price 1991) and from these
have come abundant artefacts and ecofacts to examine such issues as site
structure, chaînes opératoires and contextual associations at the scale of both the
site and region. The dictum that archaeologists should dig for relationships
not facts (Binford 1964) has become standard Palaeolithic practice and the
results, as this volume shows, are impressive.
However, while Palaeolithic archaeologists have made the case for the
study of economic adaptation and social change at Pleistocene timescales, they
are now faced with a wealth of detail requiring further analysis and inter-
pretation. It is time to re-examine what those relationships we are excavating
might be. In order to start this examination we have selected the individual
hominid as the focus for this book. We are aware that such a focus may not be
readily accepted, even by some of our contributors, since the Palaeolithic is
predominantly seen as the preserve of group behaviour and selection, especially
in the Earlier Palaeolithic which we concentrate upon here.
Moreover, even among those who champion the individual as the locus for
selection in a Neo-Darwinian approach the prospects for the Palaeolithic are
regarded as grim: ‘Ethnographies record the behaviour of individuals, a capacity
that is beyond the techniques of archaeology today, and in the forseeable
future’ (Kelly 1995: 340). While we disagree with Kelly’s pessimism (see
Mania and Mania, Thieme, Pope and Roberts, Petraglia, Shipton and Paddayya,
Adler and Conard this volume), neither must we confuse a richly detailed
record, where the shadow of the individual can often be seen among the stones
© Gamble, Clive; Porr, Martin, Dec 06, 2012, Hominid Individual in Context : Archaeological Investigations of Lower and M
Taylor and Francis, Hoboken, ISBN: 9780203007693