‘Opportunities and Despair, It’s All in There’:
Practitioner Experiences and Explanations of
Area Effects and Life Chances
■ Rowland Atkinson
University of Glasgow
■ Keith Kintrea
University of Glasgow
ABSTRACT
This article looks at perceptions of the link between residential location and life
chances. The idea of ‘area effects’ suggests that people’s prospects for social
engagement and economic activity are related to the neighbourhood where they
live. It permeates social and urban policy as well as theories of deprivation and
social exclusion. However, while quantitative evidence on area effects has begun to
suggest that such a link exists, there has been little evidence using qualitative data
and no contrast between the social patterns of life in deprived and more socially
diverse areas. In response to these concerns, this article uses data from in-depth
interviews with practitioners and voluntary workers in both deprived and socially
diverse neighbourhoods to throw more light on how the linkages between area
of residence and life chances are understood locally. The article concludes that
experiences of deprivation may be more entrenched and fatalistic in deprived
areas in response to a range of perceived negative impacts of area on social action
and engagement. However, this general position is also contradictory and frag-
mented depending on social position within the locale. The article concludes by
drawing out these ideas in terms of how the experience and reproduction of
poverty are theorized.
KEY WORDS
area effects / deprivation / life chances / neighbourhoods / social exclusion
437
Sociology
Copyright © 2004
BSA Publications Ltd®
Volume 38(3): 437–455
DOI: 10.1177/0038038504043211
SAGE Publications
London,Thousand Oaks,
New Delhi
Articles