Monitoring Tc Dynamics in a Bioreduced Sediment: An Investigation
with Gamma Camera Imaging of
99m
Tc-Pertechnetate and
99m
Tc-
DTPA
Nicholas T. Vandehey,* James P. O’Neil, Aaron J. Slowey, Rostyslav Boutchko, Jennifer L. Druhan,
William W. Moses, and Peter S. Nico
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 1 Cyclotron Road, Berkeley, California, USA
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: We demonstrate the utility of nuclear medical imaging technologies and a
readily available radiotracer, [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
, for the noninvasive monitoring of Fe(II)
production in acetate-stimulated sediments from Old Rifle, CO, USA. Microcosms
consisting of sediment in artificial groundwater media amended with acetate were probed
by repeated injection of radiotracer over three weeks. Gamma camera imaging was used
to noninvasively quantify the rate and extent of [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
partitioning from solution
to sediment. Aqueous Fe(II) and sediment-associated Fe(II) were also measured and
correlated with the observed tracer behavior. For each injection of tracer, curves of
99m
Tc
concentration in solution vs time were fitted to an analytic function that accounts for
both the observed rate of sedimentation as well as the rate of
99m
Tc association with the
sediment. The rate and extent of
99m
Tc association with the biostimulated sediment
correlated well with the production of Fe(II), and a mechanism of [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
reduction via reaction with surface-bound Fe(II) to form an immobile Tc(IV) species
was inferred. After three weeks of bioreduction, a subset of microcosms was aerated in
order to reoxidize the Fe(II) to Fe(III), which also destroyed the affinity of the [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
for the sediments. However,
within 3 days postoxidation, the rate of Tc(VII) reduction was faster than immediately before oxidation implying a rapid return
to more extensive bioreduction. Furthermore, aeration soon after a tracer injection showed that sediment-bound Tc(IV) is
rapidly resolubilized to Tc(VII). In contrast to the [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
, a second commercially available tracer,
99m
Tc-DTPA
(diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid), had minimal association with sediment in both controls and biostimulated sediments.
These experiments show the promise of [
99m
Tc]TcO
4
-
and
99m
Tc-DTPA as noninvasive imaging probes for a redox-sensitive
radiotracer and a conservative flow tracer, respectively.
■
INTRODUCTION
The use of medical radiotracer imaging techniques for studying
bioremediation of environmental toxins is gaining interest
bridging the fields of environmental research and medical
imaging.
1-3
Radiotracers have been used in environmental
sciences for many years over a wide range of applications due to
their ability to probe specific chemical processes.
4,5
The recent
use of nuclear medical imaging tools (i.e., gamma camera, single
photon emission computed tomography [SPECT], or positron
emission tomography [PET]) is driven by their ability to
dynamically measure the 3D distribution of radiotracers inside
sediment systems, with better than 1 cm resolution and
picomolar sensitivity.
These tools hold the potential for noninvasive, real-time
monitoring of both physical and chemical properties of porous
sediment, which is important in understanding the feedback
pathways that couple chemically and microbially induced
physical changes in pore structure and flow paths within
porous media,
6
a key question for many areas of subsurface
sciences. Specifically, the ability to simultaneously measure
hydrological properties using a conservative tracer while
measuring the location and extent of reducing microenviron-
ments using a redox-sensitive radiotracer represents a
significant new tool for understanding of the relationship
between chemical transformations and the associated porosity
and permeability evolution during reactive transport. For
example, the production of Fe(II) through microbial reduction
of iron oxides for bioremediation of metal contaminants
7,8
can
also lead to substantial changes in flow field permeability due to
biomass growth, production of methane, and precipitation of
iron, carbonates, and sulfides.
6
The relative contribution of
Fe(II) to this flow field evolution and the coupled influence of
permeability change on iron reduction in the system has been
indirectly inferred through electrodic potentials
9
but has never
been directly quantified.
With the goal of developing methods for Fe(II) detection
and evaluation of a potential conservative radiotracer, we used
Received: August 25, 2011
Revised: October 9, 2012
Accepted: October 19, 2012
Published: October 19, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© 2012 American Chemical Society 12583 dx.doi.org/10.1021/es302313h | Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 12583-12590