Gender differences and equal
opportunities in the ESL
classroom
AH Shehadeh
There is good evidence from cross-gender conversations between the
various possible combinations of native speakers (NS) and non-native
speakers (NNS) to suggest that men and women tend to use conversation
for different purposes. It would appear that men take advantage of the
conversation in a way that allows them to promote their performance/
production ability, whereas women utilize the conversation to promote
their comprehension ability. The main pedagogical conclusion to be drawn
from the available evidence is that the ESL/EFL teacher, equipped with a
good syllabus and a good methodology, should be able to engineer
situations that create equal opportunities for both males and females in all
aspects of classroom interaction. However, the article also suggests that
more empirical research needs to be done into (a) the origin(s) of gender
difference (biological/innate, psychological, or socio-cultural), and (b) its
effect on second language learning.
Introduction It has generally been assumed in the field of second language
1
(L2)
learning and teaching that there are various factors, external and
internal, which affect language learning. These factors include the role of
the first language, setting differences and the role of instruction, age
differences, individual learner differences, and gender differences. The
importance of examining these factors is that they might enable us, for
instance, to specify the nature of the input that best suits L2 learners'
comprehension, and the nature of the output which they produce at a
particular stage of their learning. For example, Larsen-Freeman (1985:
434) writes:
In input studies, the more we know about the learner—not only his or
her LI, but also his or her age, socioeconomic status, target language
proficiency, sex, opportunities for interaction with target language
speakers, conditions under which the learning took place, etc.—the
more we will know about the nature of the input the learner is likely
to receive.
Knowing the extent to which these factors, gender included, affect L2
learning and teaching may provide us with insights which help L2
teachers make language learning more effective. Viewed from this
perspective, it follows that gender differences may have implications for
L2 learning, teaching, and assessment (Swann 1992). As will be shown
below, empirical studies and observations have indeed shown that
256 ELT Journal Volume 53/4 October 1999 © Oxford University Press 1999
at United Arab Emirates University on April 28, 2012 http://eltj.oxfordjournals.org/ Downloaded from