1528
Author’s Note: I thank Michael Burawoy for his invaluable guidance throughout this project and his
thoughtful comments on multiple drafts of this article. Thanks also to Victoria Bonnell and the members
of the Sociology Working Group at the Berkeley Program in Soviet and Post Soviet Studies for their help-
ful feedback.
American Behavioral Scientist
Volume 49 Number 11
July 2006 1528-1553
© 2006 Sage Publications
10.1177/0002764206288848
http://abs.sagepub.com
hosted at
http://online.sagepub.com
Transnational Politics
and Settlement Practices
Post-Soviet Immigrant
Churches in Rome
Cinzia Solari
University of California–Berkeley
Conventionally, social scientists regard immigrant churches as settlement institutions with
immigrant assimilation as their goal. This study of Ukrainian immigrants who flooded
to Rome in the wake of the collapse of the Soviet Union enhances an understanding of
the role of immigrant churches by revealing their place in transnational politics. The
divergent projects of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic church (UGCC) and the Russian
Orthodox church (ROC) mediate relations between clergy and immigrant parishioners
in Rome. The UGCC engages in an ethnonationalist project; priests see settlement
practices as an opportunity to instill national and religious consciousness in Ukrainians
expected to return and participate in constructing the new Ukrainian nation. By con-
trast, the ROC’s project is one of church revival and manifests itself in the politically
charged building of a cathedral next door to the Vatican. Ukrainian parishioners are
marginal and even detrimental to this political vision. Russian Orthodox priests do not
engage in settlement practices or support immigrants’ transnational ties.
Keywords: migration; religion; Ukraine; Greek Catholicism; Russian Orthodoxy
S
ince the collapse of the Soviet Union, people from this region have been migrat-
ing in search of work. Ukrainians began entering Italy in significant numbers
during the past decade to fill the increasing demand for in-home cleaning and caring
services. This influx has challenged the Ukrainian Greek Catholic church (UGCC)
and the Russian Orthodox church–Moscow patriarchate (ROC) in Rome to minister
to this growing immigrant population.
1
I found myself conducting fieldwork in Rome during a particularly charged political
period. After a contested 2004 presidential election, mass protests known as the Orange
Revolution broke out in Ukraine, and the Ukrainian community in Rome mobilized
demonstrations in solidarity. As I went from church to church during those weeks, I saw
that the Greek Catholic and Russian Orthodox clergy had divergent reactions to the