Journal of Electrical and Control Engineering JECE
JECE Vol. 3 No. 5, 2013 PP. 1-12 www.joece.org/ © American V-King Scientific Publishing
1
Electrical Network’s Modeling & Simulation Tools:
The State of the Art.
(Case Study of NMSS platform).
TAMALI Mohammed
*1
, ALLALI Malika
2
, BOUZIDI Boumediene
3
, & TOUMI Toufik
4
ENERGARID Lab./Bechar University, URER/MS Adrar, Algeria, SONELGAZ Bechar, Algeria
Po Box 417, Kenadsa St., Bechar, Algeria
*1
mtamali@gmail.com;
2
malikaa450@gmail.com;
3
boudi08@yahoo.fr;
4
toufiktoumi@yahoo.fr
Abstract: Scientific Software are classified into three categories,
business-specific tools designed by company itself and for its
proper needs and uses, industrial products planned and
designed for general/commercial uses and finally those
institutional designed by academic institutions depending on
research need of their laboratories.
For the first category, platform should meet purely localized
and specific tasks of company. Generally used by company
itself and named proprietary solution. Second category, tools
are planned and manufactured to meet a lot of tasks. These
platforms are a licensed solution. Third case is an institutional
category where specific codes are written first to meet a
specific need in a very specialized problem and then
supercharged with additional modules in next versions and
updates until a complete software would be born. These are
called institution-made solution.
Our paper discusses in a general overview about structural
and functional characteristics of commonly used software for
modelling & simulation of electrical networks.
Solutions from the three categories are studied and their main
features are described and compared according to criteria of
performance evaluation.
We introduce later, our NMSS solution (Network Modelling &
Simulation System). The modules and their functionalities are
exposed to highlight similarities and disparities with other
solutions.
Keywords: Modelling; Simulation; Numerical Library; GUI
Software Component; Electrical Network
I. INTRODUCTION
The proposal of a specialized product may, in most
occasions, be more general and meets to a part of the
customer's request. Therefore, the client uses must comply
with the conditionings of the platform.
In case of an academic solution, it should be noted that
the need for a development team is much needed. Major
obstacle to initiate research, since no support and
stimulation are observed unless this represents a major topic
of tasks to be performed by research Laboratory.
Many software products for modelling and simulating
electrical networks already exist.
Products efficiency, used to design an eventual electrical
network is significantly dependent on modules set to predict
the behavior of studied system under normal or abnormal
operating.
Manual evaluation is possible for small electrical
systems but is expensive in engineering time. In addition,
the manual computation methods are not obvious for safety
reasons and under cases where the all design is much more
expensive and requires more efforts. The consequences of a
faulty design of electrical network model can induce:
• Danger threatening human lives if adopted.
• Increase of total costs of design and its
implementation.
• Poor Reliability/robustness of outcomes
• High costs for repair operations and maintainability.
• Causing damage to the network (incorrect decision
due to misalignment of the load level with respect to
supply request).
For designing reliable electrical networks, engineer
needs specialized potential human resources and appropriate
set of tools.
Modern numerical methods provide a fast and accurate
calculation of electrical system behaviours and network
topologies, once data and parameters were given to platform
running required software. Study of electrical network can
be quite large and it is very desirable that the engineer has a
reliable software tool that uses GUI to acquire data. In the
same way, engineer must have access to calculation results
in a clear, and unambiguous report.
In this paper, we examine some-well known platforms
software issued from academic and/or commercial category
and designed by professionals of electrical engineering field
and their development team. These teams have acquired
practice over the time. Software products are presented in
what follows without any classification or preference
ordering but just an enumeration as an example.
Notifications of characteristics are even reported.
NMSS, a solution we developed is exposed and
compared according to the same criteria.
II. EVALUATION CRITERIA MODEL
Software tools studied are technically compared under
the following criteria and recommendations:
- The Graphical User Interface, GUI
- Accessibility to visual components
- Modularity of all platform