55
Sustainable Maritime Transportation and Exploitation of Sea Resources – Rizzuto & Guedes Soares (eds)
© 2012 Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-62081-9
Endplate effect propellers: A numerical overview
Stefano Gaggero & Stefano Brizzolara
Department of Naval Architecture, Marine Engineering and Electrical Engineering (DINAEL),
Genoa University, Genoa, Italy
ABSTRACT: Energy saving is a primary objective, historically the first and, probably still now, the most
important one, in the design of marine propellers. Modern design approaches, like fully numerical lifting
line/lifting surface codes and optimization applied to potential panel methods satisfy this objective and
allow to design conventional propellers with maximum efficiency for a given operating point. On the other
hand nonconventional propellers, like CLT and Kappel like geometries, represent a further opportunity
to increase efficiency and reduce the risk of cavitation. In the present work a numerical analysis of uncon-
ventional propellers will be carried out. Two different numerical approaches, a potential panel method and
a RANS solver will be employed. The analysis will highlights the peculiarities of these kind of propellers,
the possibility to increase efficiency and reduce cavitation risk, in order to exploit the design approaches
already well proven for conventional propellers also in the case of these unconventional geometries.
main advantages of CLT propellers, higher values
of efficiency (thus lower fuel consumption, air pol-
luting lower emissions), higher value of thrust per
unit area (thus higher ship speed and lower opti-
mum diameter), lower noise and vibration levels
with better margin for face cavitation and cavita-
tion inception speed.
The gain in efficiency is obtained by the dis-
placement of the maximum load towards the tip,
that is made possible, without high noise and
energy losses (typical of tip loaded conventional
propellers) by the presence of the endplate. In fact
the outer radial sections of the blade contribute
more efficiently to the generation of thrust: veloci-
ties are higher and, geometrically, local pitch angle
is lower, i.e., the local lift is more “aligned” with
the axial propeller direction. A way to achieve high
efficiency is, thus, to produce the most part of the
required propeller thrust in this region of the blade.
The additional span (but not in the radial direc-
tion!) provided by the endplate lets to locate the
maximum load near the blade tip with a gradual
and smooth reduction of the loading curve. In this
way it is possible to avoid the presence of a strong
tip vortex and higher values of induced velocities
on the propeller plane, whose effect on the hydro-
dynamic pitch is fundamental in achieving high
values of efficiency.
The presence of the endplate itself, that increases
the pressure difference on the tip region, and lets to
adopt a finite chord at tip, produces higher value
of thrust per unit area and a local unload of the
sections. The resulting smaller optimum diameter
lets the propeller to operate in a more uniform
1 INTRODUCTION
Energy saving is a primary objective in the design
of marine propellers. The constant increase of oil
price, the more strict regulations in terms of air
pollution and the limits for NO
X
and SO
X
emissions
require more and more efficient designs. At the
same time, also requirements in term of radiated
noise and vibration emissions became more strict:
avoid negative effects on marine life and reduce the
risk of hydro-acoustic signature are the primary
aims of new commercial and navy constructions.
Unconventional propellers, like Contracted and
Loaded Tip (CLT) propellers, represent a valid
answer to all these demands that can be fulfilled
without the employment of completely different
propulsive solutions, like contra- and co-rotating
propellers or by the adoption of ducts, stators or
wake regularizers.
The first concept of tip loaded propellers goes
back to late seventies: Tip Vortex Free propellers
were the first application of the Loaded Tip con-
cept, that quickly evolved toward the CLT solution
when also contraction of the fluid vein has been
taken into account for the definition of the optimal
geometry (www.sistemar.com).
CLT propellers are characterized by a monot-
onic increase of pitch from blade root to tip, a
finite chord at tip, moderate values of skew and
an endplate at the outermost radial edge of the
blade towards the pressure side. Full scale installa-
tions and observations, together with model scale
measures and theoretical studies, as reported by
SISTEMAR (wws.sistemar.com) identified, as the