The Legitimacy of Single Mothers in
Israel Examined through Five Circles
of Discourse
Anat Herbst
ABSTRACT: This study applies critical discourse analysis to examine the
relationship between the imagery and the legitimacy attached to single
mothers, as well as the social policy designed for them. The correlation
between images, legitimacy, and policy was examined during three
decades (the 1970s, 1990s, and 2000s) of extensive legislation pertaining
to single-parent mothers. The data have been drawn from a diversity
of sources, including Knesset debates, Knesset committee discussions,
women’s organizations, the media, and semi-structured interviews.
The study shows that welfare policy necessarily encapsulates cultural
perceptions and basic assumptions pertaining to certain segments of
society. These beliefs anchor justiications for the expansion or limitation
of social rights and reveal how the development of social rights is linked
to cultural and social apprehension.
KEYWORDS: dependence, legitimacy, marginality, poverty, single moth-
ers, welfare policy
The current research applies critical discourse analysis to examine interre-
lations between the prevailing imagery ascribed to single mothers in Israeli
society, their social legitimacy, and the welfare policy shaped for them.
Women’s organizations, the Knesset and its various committees, and the
media have served as the arena in which this imagery has manifested itself.
These connections are explored through the development over time of wel-
fare policies and of laws, namely, the Child Support (Payment Assurance)
Law of 1972, the Single Parent Family Law of 1992, and the Omnibus Law
of 2003. The study takes an in-depth look at the periods in which these laws
were legislated, exposing the inluences of basic cultural assumptions and
Israel Studies Review, Volume 28, Issue 2, Winter 2013: 228–246 © Association for Israel Studies
doi: 10.3167/isr.2013.280214 • ISSN 2159-0370 (Print) • ISSN 2159-0389 (Online)