The Journal of Social Psychology, 2013, 153(5), 598–618
Copyright © Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Some Implications of Beliefs in Altruism,
Free Will, and Nonreductionism
RAYMOND MICHAEL BERGNER
ABBY RAMON
Illinois State University
ABSTRACT. In this research, we explored correlates of individuals’ beliefs in altruism,
free will, and nonreductionism, as opposed to contrasting beliefs in psychological
egoism, determinism, and biological reductionism. Beliefs in altruism, free will, and
nonreductionism were associated with heightened a) senses of meaning in life, b) levels
of life satisfaction, c) beliefs in morality as a legitimate and important dimension of life,
and d) standards of personal moral conduct; they were not associated with levels of social
isolation. Implications of these findings are discussed.
Keywords: altruism, belief systems, determinism, free will, love, psychological egoism,
reductionism
A CERTAIN CLUSTER OF BELIEFS, often put forth as compatible with a
modern scientific outlook, is becoming increasingly prevalent in the American
and other cultures (Nagel, 2012; Paulhus & Carey, 2011; Polt, 2012; Tallis, 2011).
These beliefs are the following: a) that all human behavior is essentially self-
interested—i.e., is enacted for the self’s own benefit (versus that it is sometimes
enacted out of an unselfish caring for another’s well-being); b) that all behav-
ior is determined (versus genuinely chosen); and c) that all human psychological
phenomena (thoughts, motives, decisions, beliefs, etc.) are reducible to (i.e., are
nothing over and above) brain and other biological processes (versus that they are
not so reducible). The purpose of this research is not to argue either the intel-
lectual merits of these beliefs or the contention that having a modern scientific
outlook requires them. The purpose, rather, is to explore (for the first time in two of
these cases) some important differences in peoples’ lives that may be empirically
associated with them.
Address correspondence to Raymond Michael Bergner, Illinois State University,
Department of Psychology, 440 DeGarmo Bldg., Normal, IL 61790-4110, USA; rmbergn@
ilstu.edu (e-mail).
598