© Kamla-Raj 2014 J Soc Sci, 38(1): 33-42 (2014)
Critical Thinking in Open and Distance Learning Programmes:
Lessons from the University of South Africa’s NPDE Programme
Vuyisile Msila
College of Education, University of South Africa, PO Box 392, UNISA 0003 South Africa
E-mail: msilavt@unisa.ac.za
KEYWORDS Applying Learning. Multi-skilling. Paradigm Shift. Teacher Education. Self-reflection
ABSTRACT Teaching learners to be critical has become more important in education currently. Prospective
employers and institutions of higher learning expect learners to be able to transfer learning to various situations.
This study sought to investigate the utilisation of critical thinking skills in distance education. It was a qualitative
study that explored experiences of teachers who were registered at the University of South Africa’s National
Professional Diploma in Education (NPDE) programme. Interviews and observations were used to collect data. It
was discovered that teacher education programmes should be the breeding place for critical teachers. The major
implication was that without a methodical preparation of teachers, countries will struggle having critical learners.
INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
Pascarella and Umbach (2012) point out that
one particular goal of higher education is the
development of critical thinking skills. Rowles
et al. (2013) also concur that the fostering of
critical thinking has become an expectation of
many current faculty in higher education. Fur-
thermore, they point out that it matters how
teaching staff defines critical thinking because
it has an effect on how they will address the
challenge to promote it. Students who frequent-
ly report on their positive empowerment are
those who are critical thinkers. In a country where
examiners are usually concerned with student
cheating in examinations, it will help if examina-
tions test critical thinking rather than rote learn-
ing or memory recall. Teacher training pro-
grammes need to stress critical thinking because
it is through empowered teachers that society
can have critical learners in schools. Duran and
Sendag (2012) opine that critical thinking is based
on relating and drawing conclusions on notions
and events. Furthermore, these authors say it
involves different cognitive processes such as
implicating problem solving, reflecting and crit-
icising. All these are skills necessary to live in
today’s world. Duran and Sendag (2012: 241)
aver:
Thinking begins with a physical or psycho-
logical inconvenience stemming from lacking
the solution for a problem whose solution be-
comes the objective for an individual. Higher
order thinking skills, like critical thinking and
problem solving are considered necessary skills
for 21
st
century individuals.
All education institutions should be using
these skills. Learners need higher order thinking
skills if education is to make any sense. Shan-
non and Bennett (2012) cite a number of authors
who observed that critical thinking evolves with
the following stages:
Apply - The students use knowledge and
understanding to complete a practical task;
Analyse -While working on a practical task,
the students break things down into their
component parts;
Synthesise - The students then will be able
to combine and integrate various sources
of information; and
Evaluate – At the end of the task comple-
tion, the students will be able to assess the
value, merit or worth of something.
All these are aspects that were part of the
programme under study. This article looks at how
a teacher in-service programme, The National
Professional Diploma in Education (NPDE) at-
tempted to apply the notions of critical thinking.
The article is first part of preliminary study that
is followed by an empirical study that tested the
NPDE’s students’ actual experiences in the pro-
gramme. The main question posed in this study
was: How did the classrooms of NPDE gradu-
ates experience critical thinking?
The secondary questions were:
What were the special experiences of the
teachers?
Objectives of the Study
This study seeks to investigate the role of
critical thinking in one programme that was of-