The Implementation of Public Policy:
Still the Missing Link
Robbie Waters Robichau and Laurence E. Lynn Jr.
Although theories of public policy and theories of governance both seek to establish relationships
between policymaking and its consequences, they do not complement each other very well. Public policy
models tend to de-emphasize that which governance theories tend to emphasize: the influence on
government performance of implementation, broadly described as the actions taken by those engaged in
administration (including managers at all levels, those engaged in service delivery, and third-party
agents) after a policy has been lawfully promulgated by elected officials and interpreted by the courts.
A comparison of a recently developed theory of public sector performance with several prominent
theories of policymaking suggests that multilevel governance theories can supply what continues to be
the missing link in public policy theories. At the same time, governance theories might be enriched by
the process modeling of public policy theories.
Introduction
The increasing use of “governance” as a conceptual frame for research on the
determinants of government performance has produced valuable insights into causal
relationships among public choice processes, public management, service delivery,
and citizen and stakeholder assessments and reactions. Paralleling these efforts,
public policy theorists have developed a variety of models to depict relationships
between policymaking processes and their outputs and outcomes. Although both
types of research seek to relate policymaking to its consequences, they do not
complement each other very well. Public policy models tend to de-emphasize that
which governance theories tend to emphasize: the influence on government perfor-
mance of implementation through administrative systems, broadly described as the
actions taken by public managers at all levels, those engaged in service delivery, and
third-party agents after a policy has been promulgated by elected officials and
interpreted by the courts.
This article offers a preliminary consideration of how theories of governance and
of public policy might better complement each other. We juxtapose a theory of
Prepared for presentation at the Next Generation Policy Workshop in Norman, Oklahoma,
February 27–29, 2008.
The Policy Studies Journal, Vol. 37, No. 1, 2009
21
0190-292X © 2009 Policy Studies Organization
Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc., 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA, and 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford, OX4 2DQ.