DIABETES TECHNOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS
Volume 5, Number 6, 2003
© Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
Actigraphy as Metabolic Ethography: Measuring
Patterns of Physical Activity and Energy Expenditure
COL. KARL E. FRIEDL, Ph.D.
1035
T
O BETTER UNDERSTAND the relationship be-
tween physical activity and metabolic reg-
ulation, we need new measurement tools that
are accurate, inexpensive, available, and un-
tethered to a laboratory setting. Actigraphy, the
continuous measurements of motion ampli-
tude and frequency from body-worn ac-
celerometers, has been actively investigated for
applications in the measurement of patterns of
voluntary activity. In this issue of Diabetes Tech-
nology & Therapeutics, Chen et al.
1
have de-
scribed the combined use of two accelerome-
ters, mounted on the hip and the wrist, to
accurately predict energy expenditure of phys-
ical activity across a range of activity levels in
a sample of overweight women. Not only does
this approach provide the energy expenditure
associated with activity (EE
act
), it can also pro-
vide EE
act
patterns throughout the day. David
Marlowe, a former military social psychologist,
used to say that life involves motion, and a
technology such as actigraphy that quantifies
human motion can be used to describe behav-
ior, providing an important tool for ethogra-
phers. We may finally have an accurate and
practical tool for describing EE
act
patterns for
individuals with respect to meal timing and
medication, and for a variety of physical and
emotional states, providing a tool for medical
ethnographers interested in their patients’ be-
haviors. Such a method for gathering accurate
data could revolutionize our understanding of
the role of physical activity and energy balance
in health and disease, especially for weight
management.
The gold standard for total energy expendi-
ture is still a calorimeter. This group at Van-
derbilt is well known for the refined precision
of their special metabolic chamber that has a
force transducer instrumented in the floor.
2
This chamber was used as the reference
method in this study. An alternative method
that allows us to step outside of the laboratory
measures the differential elimination of stable
isotopes using deuterated
18
O water. This dou-
bly labeled water method provides precise
measurements of energy expenditure in free-
ranging subjects, but requires careful attention
to natural variations in isotope enrichment in
the ambient environments, careful handling of
specimens, and costly and time-consuming
analyses. Nevertheless, this has been a break-
through technology in military field studies, al-
lowing us to understand energy balance for
healthy individuals operating in extreme
environments.
3
Unfortunately, the greatest
problem in metabolic studies has been the
worldwide shortage of
18
O enriched to the con-
centrations needed for this research, and this
method only provides energy expenditures in
24–48–h periods. A third method to obtaining
estimates of EE
act
involves more pedestrian
and practical methodology developed before
doubly labeled water techniques were avail-
able, such as continuous heart rate monitoring.
Despite the large sacrifices in accuracy, esti-
U.S. Army Research Institute of Environmental Medicine, Natick, Massachusetts.
Analysis