A. Srivastava, M. Shahidehpour
Restructuring Choices
for the Indian Power Sector
T
he interest in restructuring and
reform of the power sector is a
worldwide phenomenon that is being
pursued in different formats, depend-
ing on the structure and condition of
the economy and political institutions
in those countries. Yet the core of the
reform remains the same, i.e., the es-
tablishment of a transparent regulatory
structure, unbundling of the power
sector, creation of national and state
grids with a transparent and efficient
dispatch, entry and exit systems for
participants, wholesale market in the
power sector, more choices regarding
the sales to consumers, and other mea-
sures that can improve the competition
and the efficiency of the sector.
The experience of reform/restructuring in different countries
has shown that the restructuring generally fails on account of
missing pieces in the reform legislation. The restructuring pro-
grams were less successful if they were not clearly defined in a
reasonable time schedule or if they led to setting up ambiguous
regulatory structures that decided on rules regarding tariffs, en-
try to the power sector, etc. The other possible reason for failure
was attributed to the fact that reform was not an integrated pro-
gram that could look at the restructuring requirements of all the
players, i.e., generation, transmission, and distribution in the
power sector, or the reform program did not remove the poten-
tial for political interference in the working of entities and in ar-
eas other than policies.
The Indian power sector is presently going through a pro-
cess of reform and restructuring, as is the trend in many other
parts of the world. Independent regulatory commissions are
being set up, and vertically integrated utilities are being
unbundled into corporate entities. Efforts are also being made
to facilitate competition wherever feasible, and the choice of
an appropriate power market model assumes significance in
this context. The recent reforms in the Indian power sector
have exemplified changes in the players’ role for providing
policy directions, regulating, and running the sector for over 50
years. New institutional entities are being established in the
power sector, and a healthy relation-
ship between these institutions is
presumed crucial to ensure a sus-
tained development of the sector and
to realize the reform goals.
Indian Power Sector
The power sector in India has been
regulated and owned for many years
by various government agencies
and organizations. The role and the
participation of private industry in
the Indian power sector has been
limited and confined to specific ar-
eas of small jurisdiction and con-
sumer base. The subject of
electricity is covered under the con-
current list in the Constitution of In-
dia, implying that both the central and state governments have
the power to legislate the sector. The power supply industry in
India is now over a century old and experienced a slow and
fragmented growth during the first 50 years of its existence.
The enactment of the Electricity (Supply) Act in 1948 led to
the consolidation of the power industry, initially at the state
level and later at regional levels, which also led to the public
sector ownership of almost the entire industry. Although the
industry made rapid strides under this setup, it is found in-
IEEE Power Engineering Review, November 2002 0272-1724/02/$17.00©2002 IEEE 25
This article summarizes a full report that is available at on the Web, http://mo-
tor.ece.iit.edu/India. A. Srivastava and M. Shahidehpour are with the Center for
Electric Power and Power Electronics, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago,
Illinois, USA.
NREB
NEREB
EREB
SREB
WREB
Figure 1. Regional electricity boards of India
A three-phase, nine-step
action plan for reform
encourages an integrated national
grid, tariff setting, DSM options,
energy conservation, and T&D
loss reduction as possible
strategies to overcome the
problem of power deficit