Performance Analysis of Fractional Frequency Reuse Based on Worst Case Signal
to Interference Ratio in OFDMA Downlink Systems
Sherief Hashima, Masoud Alghoniemy Osamu Muta,
Hiroshi Furukawa Hossam Shalaby Department of Electrical Engineering
Electronics & Communications
Department
Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria
University
Center for Japan-Egypt
Cooperation in Science and
Technology (EJUST Center)
Egypt Japan University of science
and technology (EJUST)
Alexandria, Egypt Kyushu University
Alexandria, Egypt saidelnoubi@yahoo.com Fukuoka, Japan
sherif.mostafa@ejust.edu.eg alghoniemy@alexu.edu.eg muta@ait.kyushu-u.ac.jp
shalaby@ieee.org furuhiro@ait.kyushu-u.ac.jp
Abstract— Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) is an
efficient method to mitigate Inter Cell Interference in
multicellular Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple
Access (OFDMA) systems. In this paper, we analyze the
downlink worst case Signal to Interference Ratio for
FFR schemes. A closed form expression is derived
analytically for the worst SIR, outage probability, and
Spectral Efficiency (SE). The proposed analytical
technique is used to configure a FFR solution for the
downlink of OFDMA cellular system.The analysis is
performed using two-tiers cellular network with
uniform user density and for three different cases of
FFR, namely, Frequency Reuse Factor (FRF) = 3,
FRF=4 and sectored FFR. The inner radius
configuration depends on equalizing the worst SIR for
both inner and outer edges of the cell. Numerical results
show that sectored FFR yields the highest SE and low
outage probability. Sectored FFR highly balances the
needs of interference reduction and resource efficiency.
Keywords: Inter-cell interference cancellation, fractional
frequency reuse
I. INTRODUCTION
In future mobile communication systems, the
growing demand on wireless data traポc is the main
motivation of the industry and academia investment
in OFDMA based 4G networks. Several wireless
cellular standards such as the Third General
Partnership Project (3GPP) Long Term Evolution
(LTE), 3GPP2 Ultra Mobile Broadband (UMB), and
mobile Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave
Access (WIMAX) are all OFDMA cellular systems
[1]. The main interference in OFDMA system is due
to inter-cell interference (ICI) which deteriorates cell
edge user’s performance. Cell-edge users suffer from
strong interference when universal frequency or reuse
one is used; leading to poor performance at cell
edges.
ICI mitigation techniques can be grouped into
three different approaches, namely, randomization,
cancelation, and coordination [2, 3]. FFR belongs to
coordination strategy where a significant capacity
improvement can be gained by using two different
reuse factors instead of one [2]. Discussion and
evaluation of different interference management
techniques can be found in [4], [5].
Frequency reuse is the most commonly used
interference coordination technique, where
neighbouring cells do not use the same frequency
band. In particular, let 軽
頂
be the number of cells per
cluster, then clusters of size 軽
頂
share the whole
bandwidth according to the value of FRF. In
particular, each cell uses only
怠
朝
迩
of the BW; thus
neighbouring cells inside the cluster would not
interfere with each other. An obvious disadvantage of
frequency reuse is the reduction of SE due to the use
of only
怠
朝
迩
of the available BW [3, 4, and 15]. High
frequency reuse improves cell edge performance at
the expense of reducing the cell average throughput.
Figure1.Two-tier network with FFR three
FFR with reuse three was first proposed in [7] to
balance the link throughput across the coverage area
where Cell Center Users (CCUs) use universal
2013 IEEE 24th International Symposium on Personal, Indoor and Mobile Radio Communications: Fundamentals and PHY Track
978-1-4577-1348-4/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE 616