121
http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/14193-006
APA Handbook of Sexuality and Psychology: Vol. 1. Person-Based Approaches, D. L. Tolman and L. M. Diamond (Editors-in-Chief)
Copyright © 2014 by the American Psychological Association. All rights reserved.
C HAPTER 6
PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH
METHODS IN THE PSYCHOLOGICAL
STUDY OF SEXUALITY
David M. Frost, Sara I. McClelland, Jennifer B. Clark, and Elizabeth A. Boylan
In this chapter, we review issues central to the use of
phenomenological research methods in the psycho-
logical study of sexuality. Phenomenological meth-
ods are characterized by close attention to the
details of participants’ lived experience as well as an
emphasis on participants’ interpretation of their
experience. This group of methods is essential in
psychological research on sexuality because it helps
researchers to understand the phenomenon of sexu-
ality as it is experienced in everyday life and under
constant change. Beginning with a summary of the
epistemological foundations of phenomenological
research methods in psychology, we present an
overview of several popular approaches to data col-
lection and analysis that facilitate phenomenological
investigations of sexuality. Classical foundations,
future directions, limitations, advantages, and clini-
cal and policy relevance are discussed via key exem-
plar studies of sexuality-related phenomena using
phenomenological research methods.
SEXUALITY AS COMPLEX AND VARIED
PHENOMENA
Human sexuality is complex, given that it is inclusive
of a number of related, but distinct, phenomena.
These phenomena include, but are not limited to,
sexual behavior, desire, pleasure, orientation, and
identity. Psychologists and other social scientists
often operationalize these aspects of sexuality cate-
gorically at the level of groups and populations to
facilitate comparative study (e.g., heterosexual vs.
sexual minority; penetrative vs. nonpenetrative sex).
However, within these groups and categories, psy-
chological experiences of sexuality-related phenom-
ena are enormously varied. For example, people vary
greatly in the content and object of their sexual
desires, hold complex and multiple sexual identity
structures, imbue their own and others’ sexual behav-
iors with subjective meanings, and become energized to
engage in sexual behavior by diverse motivations (see
Chapters 10, 19, 20, and 25, this volume). In addition
to this high degree of interpersonal or within-group
variability, there is also a great deal of intrapersonal
variability in the psychological experience of sexuality.
As people develop over time and move between social
contexts, their psychological experiences of sexuality
often follow suit. Thus, for any given person, sexual
desires, identities, behaviors, and motives may change
from one moment to the next. With all of these varia-
tions in mind, researchers are tasked with developing
and using methods that are able to adequately capture
the diversity of individuals’ psychological experiences
of sexuality, including the multitude of dimensions
within the experience of sexuality.
In addition, pressing clinical concerns in the area
of sexuality require both a nuanced understanding of
people’s subjective meanings of their experience of
sexuality and an identification of possible ways to
intervene (see Volume 2, Chapter 4, this handbook).
For example, researchers have addressed a number of
issues, including the following with which we have
engaged in our own research: how same-sex couples
negotiate experiences of stigma and intimacy within
long-term romantic relationships (Frost, 2011b),
what motivations gay men have for seeking