Adsorption (2009) 15: 1–12
DOI 10.1007/s10450-009-9154-0
Behavior of ethylene and ethane within single-walled carbon
nanotubes. 1-Adsorption and equilibrium properties
Fernando J.A.L. Cruz · Erich A. Müller
Received: 20 March 2008 / Revised: 13 January 2009 / Accepted: 9 February 2009 / Published online: 28 February 2009
© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2009
Abstract Endohedral adsorption properties of ethylene and
ethane onto single-walled carbon nanotubes were investi-
gated using a united atom (2CLJQ) and a fully atomistic
(AA-OPLS) force fields, by Grand Canonical Monte Carlo
and Molecular Dynamics techniques. Pure fluids were stud-
ied at room temperature, T = 300 K, and in the pressure
ranges 4 × 10
−4
<p< 47.1 bar (C
2
H
4
) and 4 × 10
−4
<
p< 37.9 bar (C
2
H
6
). In the low pressure region, isotherms
differ quantitatively depending on the intermolecular poten-
tial used, but show the same qualitative features. Both po-
tentials predict that ethane is preferentially adsorbed at low
pressures, and the opposite behavior was observed at high
loadings. Isosteric heats of adsorption and estimates of low
pressure Henry’s constants, confirmed that ethane adsorp-
tion is the thermodynamically favored process at low pres-
sures. Binary mixtures of C
2
H
4
/C
2
H
6
were studied under
several (p, T ) conditions and the corresponding selectivities
towards ethane, S , were evaluated. Small values of S< 4
were found in all cases studied. Nanotube geometry plays
a minor role on the adsorption properties, which seem to
be driven at lower pressures primarily by the larger affinity
of the alkane towards the carbon surface and at higher pres-
sures by molecular volume and packing effects. The fact that
the selectivity towards ethane is similar to that found earlier
on carbon slit pores and larger diameter nanotubes points
to the fact that the peculiar 1-D geometry of the nanotubes
provides no particular incentive for the adsorption of either
species.
F.J.A.L. Cruz · E.A. Müller ( )
Department of Chemical Engineering, Imperial College London,
South Kensington Campus, London SW7 2AZ, UK
e-mail: e.muller@imperial.ac.uk
Keywords Adsorption · Molecular simulation · Carbon
nanotubes · Ethylene · Ethane · Grand canonical Monte
Carlo · Molecular dynamics
1 Introduction
Separations of close boiling point mixtures, such as the
ethylene/ethane mixture, are amongst the most energy-
intensive unit operations in chemical and petrochemical
plants, where they usually involve low-temperature distil-
lation techniques. For this type of separations, encompass-
ing structurally and/or energetically similar molecules, al-
ternative techniques are actively sought, particularly for
small-scale applications such as those used in the phar-
maceutical, biomedical and aerospace industry (Noble and
Agrawal 2005). While adsorption using nanoporous mate-
rials is posed to be considered as an option, our current
molecular-level knowledge of the physical phenomena in-
volved in the adsorption and diffusion of fluids in confined
nanospaces still needs improvement.
Molecular simulation has played a key role in under-
standing the intricate details of the cooperative adsorption of
ethane and ethylene. To date, two types of adsorbents have
been proposed for the separation of this kind of mixtures;
zeolites (Al-Baghli and Loughlin 2006; Da Silva and Ro-
drigues 1999) and π -complexation sorbents (Yang 2003).
The separation using zeolites is kinetic in nature, i.e. the
separation is based on the distinct diffusivities of the species.
On the other hand, π -complexation sorbents are designed by
doping conventional adsorbents with cations (usually Cu
+
or Ag
+
) that have a high affinity with the double bond
present in alkenes. While selectivity in these latter adsor-
bents is high, regeneration of the adsorbent is an issue if
continuous processing is required. In this context, the quest