Sciknow Publications Ltd. OJSSR 2014, 2(1):17-22
Open Journal of Social Science Research DOI: 10.12966/ojssr.03.02.2014
©Attribution 3.0 Unported (CC BY 3.0)
The Reflection of Urban Identity in Novel: A Case Study of Dublin
in James Joyce’s Dubliners
Behrooz Mahmoodi Bakhtiari
1,*
, Negin Sajadi
2
1
Associate Professor, Department of Performing Arts, University of Tehran
2
MA Graduate of English Literature, Kharazmi University, Tehran
*Corresponding author (Email: mbakhtiari@ut.ac.ir)
Abstract - City, a place in which many historical and social events transpired, is in close touch with literature. This article tries to
study the reflection of urban identity in James Joyce‟s Dubliners within the frameworks provided by Kevin Lynch (1984) and
(1960). Lynch (1984) defines identity as the extent of which people could identify an environment and made it unique. He has
argued that there was a bilateral relationship between the images of city and observer; he suggested that place identity and
personal identity were in close contact with each other, so urban identity could be identified in place. In surveying form and the
images of Joyce‟s Dublin, Kevin Lynch‟s “theory of urban form‟‟ (1960) and “theory of good city‟‟ (1984) were applied. And
also according to the fact that personal identity is dependent on human capitals, Pierre Bourdieu‟s (1977) concepts of “capital‟‟,
“habit‟‟, and “field‟‟, that are effective in shaping urban identity, in his t heory of power and practice was used.
Keywords - Dublin, Identity, Urban, City, Image
1. Introduction
The main aim of this study is to survey the reflection of urban
identity of Dublin in James Joyce‟s Dubliners based on Kevin
Lynch‟s and Pierre Bourdieu‟s theories, which has not been
regarded in latter studies of Dubliners. Identity, according to
Webster‟s Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary, is “the
distinguishing character or condition of a person or a thing‟‟.
Lynch (1984: 131) believes that “identity is the extent of
which a person can recognize or recall a place as being
distinct from other places, as having a vivid, or unique, or at
least a particular, character of its own‟‟. He suggests that
“place identity is closely linked to personal identity‟‟ (ibid:
132), thus urban identity can be manifested through this
connection.
Urban identity is influenced by the space-structure. The
importance of place identity is mentioned by Relph (1976:147)
in the book Place and Placelessness:
“A deep human need exists for associations with
significant places. If we choose to ignore that need, and
follow the forces of placelessness to continue unchallenged,
then the future can only hold an environment in which places
simply do not matter. If, on the other hand, we choose to
respond to that need and transcend placelessness, then the
potential exists for the development of an environment in
which places are for man, reflecting and enhancing the variety
of human experience‟‟.
Also Walmsley (1988:64) believes that what happens in
the city is in line with the urban identity, he suggests that
“...human intent and action ascribe meaning and transform
empty space into experienced place...with their values and
actions‟‟.
Harold Bloom (2005) in the introduction of Bloom’s
literary places writes that the presence of city in novels has a
long background, and dates back to ancient Alexandria. Cities
are represented in the works of many authors. There is no
separation between the work and the represented city. As
Bloom (ibid,ix,x) asserts Athens is not isolated from Iliad,
Thebes from Odyssey, London from the Elizabethan-
Jacobean literature, Paris from Balzac, London from Dickens,
New York City from Whitman and Melville, Oxford and
Mississippi from Faulkner‟s works, and Washing, D.C. from
political novelists, like Henry Adams and Gore Vidal. In
Bloom’s literary places, the history and geography of Dublin,
London, New York, Paris Rome, and St. Petersburg are
surveyed. Researchers study special writers‟ homelands and
the places that motivate them in writing their works. For
example in studying Fyodor Mikhailovich Dostoevsky‟s
works, Woodworth and Richards (2005: 71) show that how
Dostoevsky‟s writing is associated with St. Petersburg. They
conclude that Petersburg is not just a social setting of his
novels; it is the city that its physical features attribute to its
inhabitants‟ characteristics.
Also Ulla Hakanen (2010) in “Panoramas from Above and
Street from Below”, surveys the diaries of two Russian
modernist writers, Vyacheslav Ivanov and Mikhail Kuzmin.