National narratives, institutional ideologies, and local talk:
The discursive production of Spanish in a “new”
US Latino community
PHILLIP M. CARTER
Program in Linguistics, Florida International University
Deuxième Maison 453, 11200 SW 8th Street Miami, FL 33199, USA
pmcarter@fiu.edu
ABSTRACT
This study investigates the figuration of “Spanish” as a sociocultural dis-
course within the context of a middle school in North Carolina, where
immigration from Latin America is new, yet quickly accelerating. The
school-based discourse is analyzed in terms of everyday ways of talking
among students, as well as institutional ideologies and practices, which
mediate national discourses about US Latinos and reinforce tropes circulated
by students. Everyday ways of talking among non-Latino students suggest
that Latinos—both immigrants and US born—are Spanish monolinguals
who “choose” to be segregated from the English speakers. The use of
Spanish by Latinos is constructed by non-Latinos as secretive and dangerous,
linking local tropes about Spanish to national discourses. Consistent informal
pressure against Spanish at school links to broader pressures against Spanish
in the community and beyond. The discourse problematizes Latino identity
formations and limits the types of identities available to Latino students.
(Discursive production, Spanish, US Latinos, Latino threat narrative)*
INTRODUCTION
National discourses about US Latinos, immigration, and Spanish have proliferated
in the United States over the past two decades, ebbing and flowing in both quantity
and vitriol, as Chavez (2008:34) points out, with global and national economic con-
ditions, the broader political climate, and the demand for cheap labor. These dis-
courses construct US Latinos, both immigrants and the US-born, as Spanish
monolinguals, unable or unwilling to learn English, who, “flood,”“invade,” or
“infect” the US (Santa Ana 2002), depleting local budgets and draining resources
from cities, states, and the nation. Intersecting with ideologies of English monolin-
gualism (Macías 1985; Wiley & Lukes 1996; Wiley 2000; Santa Ana 2002) and
standard language (Lippi-Green 1994, 1997; Silverstein 1996), U.S. popular dis-
courses about Spanish have, over time and with great repetition, come to constitute
hegemonic ways of thinking and talking about US Latinos, and produce as their
© Cambridge University Press, 2014 0047-4045/14 $15.00 209
Language in Society 43, 209–240.
doi:10.1017/S0047404514000049