Effects of Organic and Conventional Management of Sugar Cane
Crop on Soil Physicochemical Characteristics and
Phosphomonoesterase Activity
Luiza L. A. Purcena,*
,†
Maria Carolina B. Di Medeiros,
†
Wilson M. Leandro,
‡
and Ka ́ tia F. Fernandes
†
†
Departamento de Bioquı ́ mica e Biologia Molecular, ICB II, e
‡
Escola de Agronomia e Engenharia de Alimentos, Universidade
Federal de Goia ́ s, Samambaia Goiâ nia, Brazil
ABSTRACT: Soil enzymes play an important role in agriculture and particularly in nutrient cycling. They are also involved in
the degradation, transformation, and mineralization of organic matter and availability of nutrients in soil. It is believed that
organic agriculture causes fewer losses to soil quality and is less aggressive to the environment than conventional management. In
this study, the effects of conventional (CM) and organic management (OM) on phosphomonoesterases, an important enzyme
for soil fertility, were evaluated and compared to those results from native Cerrado (Brazilian Savanna) soil (NS), because they
are the most common phosphatases in soils. The results showed that there were both acid (AcP) and alkaline (AkP)
phosphatases in all soils tested and that AcP activity was higher than that of AkP. In contrast to AkP, AcP had its activity affected
by land use. In the cultivated areas there was a reduction of almost 50% of AcP activity respect to native unexploited soils and
there was no significant difference between organic and CM, demonstrating that independent of the management chosen, there
was an impact of land use on AcP activity. Principal component analysis indicated that characteristics related to pH such as alkali
saturation (V%), aluminum saturation (M%), Al
3+
, soil total acidity (H+Al), and Ca
2+
are the main factors that permit
distinguishing NS from OM and CM.
KEYWORDS: phosphomonoesterases, Cerrado, soil, principal component analysis, management
■
INTRODUCTION
Soil is a complex ecosystem in which the combination of
insects, nematodes, annelids vegetation, microorganisms, and
anthropogenic modifications will determine its characteristics.
Management of agricultural systems also contributes to soil
characteristics and can affect soil quality in the long term by
modifying soil physical, chemical, and biological characteristics
at a rate that is largely dependent on climate conditions and
farming practice.
1
Cerrado, also known as the Brazilian Savanna, soils are acid
and have low availability of nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P),
potassium (K), calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), sulfur (S),
boron (B), copper (Cu), molybdenum (Mo), and zinc (Zn).
They are high in aluminum (Al) saturation and possess high P
fixation capacities.
2
In addition, Cerrado soils present crop production
limitations: 5-6 month dry season; dry spells of 1-3 weeks
during the rainy season, generally associated with high
evapotranspiration rates; low water-holding capacity, even in
clayey soils; limited rooting depth of many crops as a function
of aluminum toxicity and/or calcium deficiency in subsurface
soil layers.
3
Despite all of these problems, a breakthrough in agricultural
development has taken place in the area during recent decades,
mainly involving food crops, pasture, and coffee. Yield levels of
some of these crops exceed national averages.
3
The overexploitation of soil is a consequence of the current
needs to sustain the high demand for food and the search for
alternative fuel sources such as ethanol. The ethanol produced
from sugar cane monoculture has become very important
worldwide, because it is a viable alternative to vehicle fossil
fuels,
4
especially considering the increasing prices of oil as a
consequence of the risk of shortage. Additionally, in contrast to
oil, ethanol is a renewable energy source and reduces the
greenhouse effect of gas emissions. Moreover, gas emission
produced from sugar cane ethanol is much less aggressive than
that from corn because it decreases the use of fossil fuels by
using biomass.
4
Several authors have reported that monoculture planting
causes the loss of soil fertility because of the nutrients
consumed by plants and pesticide use.
5-7
Then, in an attempt
to lessen agricultural impacts of monocultures, several manage-
ments have been proposed, including organic management
(OM), in which only organic fertilizers are used and there is no
use of pesticides or synthetic fertilizers. Some papers have
already described the benefits of OM
1,8
by preserving some
biochemical characteristics such as the global, organic, and basal
carbon (C). Nevertheless, the impact of this management on
soil enzymes has not been evaluated yet.
Biomass and enzymes present in soil are responsible for
several chemical reactions such as nutrient cycling and the
physicochemical characteristics of this environment.
9
The
activities of enzymes in soil have been correlated with plant
growth and are reported as a useful tool to measure soil
fertility,
10,11
making them great candidates to measure soil
quality. In addition, enzymes are sensitive to environmental
changes and are more effective than microorganisms as
Received: July 22, 2013
Revised: January 21, 2014
Accepted: January 29, 2014
Published: January 29, 2014
Article
pubs.acs.org/JAFC
© 2014 American Chemical Society 1456 dx.doi.org/10.1021/jf403141w | J. Agric. Food Chem. 2014, 62, 1456-1463