International Journal of Architectural Research Camila Cociña Varas and Camillo Boano
Archnet-IJAR, Volume 7 - Issue 3 - November 2013 - (57-79) – Special Issue 57
Copyright © 2013 Archnet-IJAR, International Journal of Architectural Research
HOUSING AND RECONSTRUCTION IN CHILE (2010-2012):
Institutional and social transformation in post-disaster contexts
Camila Cociña Varas
1
and Camillo Boano
2
University College London
1
camilacocina@gmail.com
2
c.boano@ucl.ac.uk
Abstract
Stemming from the assumption that disasters present unique conditions to rethink the
associations and relationships among different actors, while acknowledging post disaster
reconstruction as a political process that may generate momentum for institutional
transformation; this article discusses the institutional responses to housing in such a
transformative moment. Grounding the empirical terrain into the 2010 Chilean earthquake,
the article is concerned with how the institutional response to housing needs has been
influenced by the neoliberal context and civil society in the aftermath of the event. Its
objective is to review the changes in housing policy over this period, and to what extent
these changes are proposing a new social order, or consolidating the existing one; to what
extent civil society claims can challenge contexts of exclusion; and to what extent the actors’
roles change or remain static. To do so, it develops a series of criteria to apply to the
reconstruction process and housing policy transformation that took place after the
earthquake. The main findings show that the institutional responses have promoted the
consolidation of a model rather than a transformative process. By contrast, social
organisations have embraced elements of transformation towards collective capability
strengthening that are not necessarily recognised by formal institutions.
Keywords: housing policy; reconstruction; Chile; institutional transformation; right to the city;
neoliberalism.
INTRODUCTION
“I propose to consider the construction of reciprocal actions and, particularly, the reciprocal
determination of subjects at the core of political practice” (Lechner, 2006:162 [author’s
translation]).
The process of production of a social order based on a reciprocal determination of different actors
is difficult to achieve. There are moments, however, that give rise to exceptional conditions that
may trigger such processes. Disasters affect both human and non-human agents, presenting
unique conditions to rethink the associations that are linking them. A disaster can imply the
strengthening or reordering of those relationships and the roles that they play. Reconstruction is a
political process that may generate momentum for institutional transformation, challenging the
position and capabilities of State, private sector and civil society alike. Due to its central role in
reconstruction, institutional responses to housing needs can play a critical role in such
transformations (Boano and Hunter, 2012).
In 2010 a devastating earthquake affected Chile’s most populous area. Its timing
coincided with the beginning of the first right-wing government in 20 years, and with the
emergence of emboldened social movements. This article is concerned with how the institutional
response to housing needs has been influenced by the neoliberal context and civil society claims
since the earthquake in 2010. Its aim is to review the changes in housing policy over this period,
and determine to what extent these changes are proposing a new social order, or consolidating