Improved Estimation of Radar Rainfall Bias
Over Klang River Basin Using a Kalman
Filtering Approach
Sharifah Nurul Huda Syed Yahya
1
, Wardah Tahir
1
, Suzana Ramli
1
Sayang Mohd Deni
2
, Hamzah
Arof
3
, Muhammad Faiz Mohamed Saaid
3
1
Faculty of Civil Engineering, Universiti Teknologi MARA,
40450 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia
2
Faculty of Computer and Mathematical Science, Universiti Teknologi MARA,
40450 Shah Alam, Selangor, Malaysia
3
Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Universiti Malaya,
50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Abstract—Bad weather, consisting of thunderstorms, normally
causes the presence of strong winds and heavy rain that may
develop into a storm over a certain area. Radar has been the
most potential and powerful instrument used to detect and
monitor the development of thunderstorms over a large area;
however, it also has certain weaknesses. Weather radar can be
affected by different sources of errors, which have to be well
considered and quantiÝed for a proper interpretation of the
collected data. We design a method that combines the Kalman
Filter with a multivariate analysis technique. The
implementation of this technique is for the purpose of
developing a formulation that may help to reduce error. These
studies involved parameters such as temperature, humidity,
point of gauge rainfall, and weather radar reflectivity. The
approach of using the Kalman Filter combined with
multivariate analysis is still a new way to improve radar
rainfall estimates by prediction (time update) and correction
(measurement update). This particular research was developed
purposefully to reduce radar rainfall bias due to the uncertain
sources of error seen in the weather radar, and many studies
have been developed, but still did not achieve suitable values
between radar readings with rain gauge returns.
Keywords- Bias; Radar Rainfall; Kalman Filter; time update;
measurement update
I. INTRODUCTION
The implementation of filtering techniques for reducing
radar rainfall error estimation is still new in Malaysia.
Previously, the Malaysian Meteorology Department (MMD)
used conventional radar, and also used the 3D-Rapid
Program, which provided virtually all of the features
required for the operation of a radar network and
distribution [1].
In early 1998 the MMD started using Doppler Weather
Radar with IRIS software as the tool to derive the rainfall
intensity map and other elements of weather data. The type
of the radar used in Malaysia for the purpose of rainfall
estimation was S-band pulse radar.
Historically, it was placed for the purpose of aviation
systems, but was also able to be used for the purpose of
weather estimation. MMD decided to use it because it is an
advanced hardware and software system that can provide
high spatial and temporal resolution rainfall information
with a detailed view of the rainstorm, and can detect air
turbulence, called “wind shear” or “down burst”. It is very
useful for the purpose of aviation systems and hydrology in
defining the weather characteristics and for the purpose of
forecasting the weather over a large area. Besides that, radar
rainfall data is affected by several errors. The normal factors
in radar rainfall that contribute to errors are ground clutter,
partial beam occultation caused by interception of terrain,
beam blockage caused by anomalous propagation as it
passes through atmospheric layers with different densities,
and attenuation effects. This is caused by atmospheric gases
and attenuation by the rainfall range, which has an effect on
radar measurement of rainfall [2]. Thus, a good
understanding in the fundamental knowledge of radar-
rainfall is needed in order to improve and to enhance the
algorithm and uncertainty analysis for the calculation of
rainfall.
One of the main advantages of using radar for rainfall
measurements is because it can cover a large area in real
time. On the other hand, getting accurate radar rainfall
estimation for hydrological applications is not a simple task.
The complexity of using radar in hydrological applications
is mainly due to error characteristics. Removing the
systematic error (bias) and enhancing the precision,
accuracy, and limitations of radar data sources will be the
main issues in promoting accuracy in measurement for radar
hydrology applications. It was reported by [3], [4], and [5]
about the procedure of bias correction. This study applies
the Kalman Filter equation in a way that will reduce the
uncertainty in radar rainfall estimation. Weather radar sends
off microwave pulses and measures various targets reflected
by the atmosphere, such as raindrops, hail, and snow. The
characteristics of weather contain elements such as
humidity, temperature, wind direction, evaporation, as well
as birds need to be considered in collecting the radar echo.
The authors would like to thank MOSTI E- Science Fund Grant (06-01-01-
SF0290)
2012 IEEE Symposium on Business, Engineering and Industrial Applications
978-1-4577-1634-8/12/$26.00 ©2012 IEEE 368