PARTICIPATORY 3D MODELLING
Information Development (ISSN 0266-6669) Copyright © 2007 SAGE Publications. Vol. 23, Nos 2/3, DOI: 10.1177/0266666907078592 113
village of Nessuit is located on the slopes of the Mau
Forest Complex and is mainly inhabited by Ogiek
people who, traditionally, used to be one of the larger
hunter-gatherer communities in Eastern Africa. The
Ogiek have used other participatory mapping methods
before, including working with aerial photographs.
This was their first opportunity to work on model
building using a fully participatory method.
Within the context of the mapping exercise this
paper focuses on the course of action and related
human dynamics which led to the production of the
map legend through a participatory process. Though
community mapping processes have many interesting
components, it can be argued that the collaborative
development of the map legend is the key process on
which the quality of a participatory mapping exercise
and its outputs depend. It is a community-developed
and universally understood map legend that allows local
spatial knowledge to be expressed in an objective and
efficient manner which may contrast with the dominant
intellectual framework which is usually presented on
‘official’ maps. When a map is used to support dialogue
or negotiations, it is particularly important that its
graphic vocabulary is fully understood by all parties
involved and each displayed feature has a key to be
objectively interpreted (Rambaldi, 2005).
BACKGROUND
The Mau Complex
The Mau Forest Complex forms the largest forest block
in Kenya, and the largest single block of closed-canopy
forest in Eastern Africa (Nkako et al., 2005). The Mau
Forest Complex is one of the five water towers in the
country, providing the upper catchments of major
watercourses, including the Nzoia, Yala, Nyando,
Sondu, Mara, Kerio, Molo, Ewaso Ngiro, Njoro,
Nderit, Makalia, and Naishi Rivers. In turn these rivers
feed major lakes, including Natron, Victoria, Turkana,
Baringo and Nakuru (Nkako, 2005). The boundaries
of the Maasai Mau Forest were agreed upon in 1987,
based on the work of the Ntutu Commission. Since the
Through the Eyes of Hunter-Gatherers:
participatory 3D modelling among Ogiek
indigenous peoples in Kenya
The participatory mapping of their ancestral
territories stimulated community cohesion among
the Ogiek indigenous people of Kenya and helped
them to appreciate their unique cultural identity and
indigenous knowledge system.
Giacomo Rambaldi, Julius Muchemi,
Nigel Crawhall and Laura Monaci
INTRODUCTION
The participatory three-dimensional modelling
(P3DM) exercise discussed in this paper is part of a
2006–2008 project aimed at ‘Strengthening the East
African Regional Mapping and Information Systems
Network’. The project was implemented by the NGO
Environmental Research Mapping and Information
Systems in Africa (ERMIS-Africa), and technically
and financially supported by the Technical Centre for
Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA) and the
Indigenous Peoples of Africa Coordinating Committee
(IPACC). In parallel to fulfilling its main objective,
the initiative provided the Ogiek indigenous people
with an opportunity to apply P3DM to their situation
of vulnerability, land and natural resource loss. The
Ogiek application of the participatory methodology
whilst mapping out their ancestral territories served
as a training ground for representatives from non-
governmental organizations (NGOs) and indigenous
peoples
1
, community-based organizations (CBOs)
from ten African countries in practicing participatory
GIS (PGIS) methods and specifically P3DM in the
contexts of collaborative natural resource management,
customary resource tenure, and safeguarding cultural
identities.
The exercise took place in the village of Nessuit,
Nakuru District, Kenya during the month of August
2006 after a 10-month preparation period. It has been
the first of its kind in Africa and has drawn from P3DM
experience in other regions of the world, in particular,
Southeast Asia and the Pacific (Rambaldi and Callosa-
Tarr, 2002; Rambaldi, Tuivanuavou et al., 2006). The