Current Pharmacogenomics and Personalized Medicine, 2011, 9, 000-000 1
1875-6921/11 $58.00+.00 © 2011 Bentham Science Publishers
Letter to the Editors
Not So Simple: Situating Postgenomics Personalized Medicine in the
Regional Context in Africa for Global and Women’s Health
Ida Ngueng-Feze
1,
*
, Alexander Borda-Rodriguez
2
and Farah Huzair
2
1
Centre of Genomics and Policy, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada;
2
Development, Policy
and Practice, The Open University, Milton Keynes, United Kingdom
Keywords: Africa, genomics and international development, global health, midwives, public health genomics, postgenomics
personalized medicine, regional context, women’s health.
TO THE EDITORS
We read with great interest the editorial analysis on
postgenomics medicine in Africa and ways in which this can
benefit global and women’s health [1]. More importantly, the
articulation of the triple integration of the biological, social
and political determinants of health to ensure equitable
global diffusion of genomics innovations in low and middle
income countries (LMICs) deserves further elaboration of
the African local context. The aim of this Letter to the
Editors is to address and ‘explicate’ the local contexts in
which health systems and services are delivered in Africa.
Without effective understanding, enlisting and cooperation
of the key ‘health actors’ in their natural setting and context,
we submit that personalized medicine, whether with
genomics or other advanced biotechnologies, will not come
to fruition. Our discussion below attests to the need for
reconciliation of local, regional and global health systems
and services in an increasingly interconnected world.
TRADITIONAL MEDICINE AND AFRICA
The World Health Organization (WHO) has published in
its reports that up to 80% of people in many developing
countries rely primarily on traditional medicine for their
health services [2]. Wherefore, traditional healers and
practitioners and this "alternate" health system should be
integrated into research parameters if research aims to be
comprehensive and fully contextualized. Understanding the
patient’s socio-cultural context is part of integrating local
advances in larger global objectives. In fact, this approach,
referred to as “cultural proficiency”, is an emerging concept,
whereby consideration is given to the patient’s culture and
perception in order to increase treatment success [3], which
is progressively integrated in fields such as pharmaco-
genomics and pharmacogenetics.
Because of their close and embedded interactions with
local communities, traditional practitioners and traditional
*Address correspondence to this author at the Centre of Genomics and Policy,
Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, 740 Dr. Penfield Avenue, Suite 5200,
Montreal, QC, Canada; Tel: (514) 398-8004; Fax: (514) 398-8954;
E-mail: inguengf@yahoo.com
birth attendants (TBAs) represent both an untapped potential
for advancing rational therapeutics as well as a risk if they
are not recognized as an important variable on the critical
path to personalized medicine in Africa. Indeed, several
African countries have started to integrate traditional healers
and practitioners in their formal health care systems.
For example, in South Africa the “Traditional Health
Practitioners Bill,” which came into force in 2006 facilitated
the integration of traditional healers in routine healthcare by
implementing the development of a pharmacopoeia of
traditional medicines [4]. This is particularly relevant to
fields such as pharmacogenomics as patients would use
healer’s herbal prescriptions in conjunction with doctor’s
medications. Several studies have acknowledged the need to
integrate practitioners as well as TBAs as they play a crucial
role in the provision of health care services. In fact, it was
estimated that 60-80% of deliveries in developing countries
occurred outside modern health care facilities, with a
significant proportion of this overseen by TBAs [5].
Additionally, studies conducted by the WHO, in three
different LMICs (Ghana, Mexico, and Bangladesh) to train
TBAs, demonstrated that training these health care providers
was not only feasible but also resulted in the improvement
of healthcare service quality, increased dissemination of
health information within the community, as well as the
empowerment of stakeholders [6]. Wherefore, if properly
trained and integrated, these “health actors” can be valuable
especially for many countries with limited resources (few
or poor infrastructure, limited funds, lack of qualified
personnel) often stretched even further by environmental
predicaments (e.g., droughts, infectious epidemics), political
turmoil (e.g., political instability, civil war, emigration) or
social barriers (e.g., superstitious beliefs, misinformation,
lack of education).
While many countries in Africa have yet to proceed
towards an integrated health system as above, it is important
that studies begin to include in research parameters,
traditional medicine as part of the cultural context which can
both facilitate or hinder the application of new technologies
in local contexts. Notably, donors have the ability to
facilitate this process by integrating these important
components into their terms of reference. This would