Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 57 No. 1, 93–107
©
Hansard Society for Parliamentary Government 2004; all rights reserved
10.1093/pa/gsh008
Political Mediation in Ireland: Campaigning
Between Traditional and Tabloid Markets
BY NEIL COLLINS AND PATRICK BUTLER
POLITICS in Ireland shares some of the ‘malaise’ characteristics of other
western democracies in relation to the mediation of the politician to the
citizen. Commentators suggest that the Irish, like others, are increasingly
disengaged from politics, frequently displaying low levels of knowledge
about their democratic institutions, and routinely effect a mistrust of
government leaders. The changing nature of the Irish media is to blame,
say critics, as market forces seem to dictate a more sensationalist and
shallow press, as well as a style of broadcast interviewing and reporting
that pitches the journalist as champion critic and the politician as artful
dodger. Almost as culpable are the political marketers with their
emphasis on politics as spin rather than substance. An alterative pers-
pective, typifes the accounts of so-called media malaise as ‘claiming
that common practices in political communications by the news media
and party campaigns hinder civic engagement’.
1
This malaise inhibits
citizens learning about public affairs, trust in government and political
activism. It is true that participation in Ireland as measured by turnout
at elections is declining and that trust in politicians has been severely
dented by the revelations about corruption of recent years. Nevertheless,
politics remains a focus of huge public interest, with current affairs chat
shows, newspaper readership and audience fgures for news and political
analysis relatively steady. Furthermore, Irish politicians still rely on
other traditional forms for mediation that are either in decline elsewhere
or are afforded little signifcance in the literature on larger political systems.
That is, the mediation of politicians in Ireland reFects broader trends
but is modifed by the impact of both the particular political system and
the structure of the national and local media.
International observers may feel familiar with Irish politics because
the vocabulary is the same as that of the UK. Indeed, the political insti-
tutions of the Republic are, for the most part, based on the Westminster
model. Each of the institutions referred to in the Irish Constitution — the
presidency, the Oireachtas (parliament), the government and the courts—
is given specifc powers, to be exercised in accordance with the general
principles of a British-style parliamentary democracy. This can lead
commentators to assume a greater degree of similarity between the
politics of the Republic and those of the UK than actually exists. The
Constitution does, however, have some signifcant features not found in